Where to stay

in Shelter Island Heights

We'd like to help you find something that checks all your boxes.

Shelter Island Heights is well-liked for its beaches, golf courses, and theaters. If you're interested in spending some time outdoors, Sunset Beach and Crescent Beach are some top places to check out. Shelter Island Country Club and Sylvester Manor are also a few notable stops. Whether you're hoping to stay right near top attractions or you'd like to be a little more tucked away, you'll be able to find your ideal accommodation in Shelter Island Heights.

Photo by Erisa Dilo

Top places to stay near the beach

The Pridwin Hotel is a hotel that comes with a private beach and a seasonal outdoor pool and is well-liked by beach travelers for its helpful staff. It's located just steps from Crescent Beach.

Recommended hotels

Best places to stay offering breakfast

The Rams Head Inn is an inn with free breakfast and free WiFi. The Pridwin Hotel is a hotel that offers free WiFi and free parking and is known for its helpful staff. Crescent Beach is located just steps from the property. Shelter Island House is a hotel with free breakfast and free WiFi.

Recommended hotels

Best places to stay for couples

The Pridwin Hotel is a hotel featuring premium bedding and a private beach that guests like for its helpful staff.

Recommended hotels

Best places to stay for families

The Pridwin Hotel is a hotel featuring a private beach and a restaurant that guests like for its helpful staff. Shelter Island House is a hotel featuring a restaurant and free parking.

Recommended hotels

Best places to stay with pools

The Pridwin Hotel is a hotel featuring a seasonal outdoor pool and a full-service spa, and guests like its helpful staff. Crescent Beach is located just steps from the property.

Recommended hotels