Simms Castle Hotels

"Wonderful "

"This was our first trip to Long Island, and it was perfect! The cottage had the most beautiful views, and we spent every evening outside watching the sun set over the water. Debbie and Phil (as well as everyone we met on the island) were extremely friendly and had great suggestions for things to do, where to eat, and places to visit. It was the perfect place to celebrate our engagement, and we will absolutely be back for the honeymoon!! Couldn’t ask for anything better! "

"Loved the entire stay. Nice breezy side of the island. "

"We loved or stay and will be back again next year!"

"Beautiful home in an AWESOME location!!"

"We stayed 3 days used kitchen and bbqLocation needs 4 wheel drive to reach Needs to be communicated ahead of time."

"Had a great stay. House was great. amazing views. Comfortable beds. Even with 8 people great space. Amazing porch. Can’t wait to come back. "

"Amazing staff!! "

"This was our second stay at Bonefish Valhalla Villa and it was just as great as the first. The setting is fantastic and the house is comfortable, well-equipped, and clean. The house manager is really helpful. Loved the whole experience!"