Top 10 Hotels in Middle Cay (from $198) 2026 - Competitive Prices

Our top choices for Middle Cay hotels

Hotel

Beach nearby, beach umbrellas, beach towels, beach yoga

1. Tingum Village Hotel

Dunmore Town

Edrin

$183 nightly

Aug 3 - Aug 4

Total with taxes and fees

2. The Cove Eleuthera

Gregory Town

Thiago

$1,129 nightly

Jul 29 - Jul 30

Total with taxes and fees

3. Valentines Resort & Marina

Dunmore Town

Inga

Two Bedroom Sea Cottage - The Sergeant Major | View from room

4. Coral Sands Inn & Cottages

Dunmore Town

Lawrence

$956 nightly

Aug 14 - Aug 15

Total with taxes and fees

5. The Rock House Hotel

Dunmore Town

TODD

Beach nearby, sun loungers, beach umbrellas, beach towels

6. Eleven Bahama House

Dunmore Town

Mary

$540 nightly

Aug 2 - Aug 3

Total with taxes and fees

7. Royal Palm Hotel

Dunmore Town

Mark

$180 nightly

Jul 29 - Jul 30

Total with taxes and fees

2 restaurants; breakfast, lunch, and dinner served

8. Pink Sands Resort

Dunmore Town

Michael

$1,160 nightly

Aug 26 - Aug 27

Total with taxes and fees

9. Romora Bay Resort & Marina

Dunmore Town

"The marina is very good the food at the restaurant was expensive but taste great We also have a sour experience at the from desk we asked for a water taxi to eluthera airport and they call fo a private taxi without tell us that was private when we got to the island they ask us to pay $70 for the ride that was 10 minutes and for the same ride before they charge us $10 each other than that the experience was nice the beach was very clean and beautiful 😍"

loisett

$477 nightly

Aug 10 - Aug 11

Total with taxes and fees

10. Runaway Hill Inn

Dunmore Town

Trent

11. Daddy Joes

Gregory Town

Alison

$169 nightly

Jul 31 - Aug 1

Total with taxes and fees

12. Spanish Wells Yacht Haven

Spanish Wells

Sean

$255 nightly

Jul 29 - Jul 30

Total with taxes and fees

13. Sky Beach Club

Governor's Harbour

Alexis

Beach nearby, beach umbrellas, beach yoga

14. The Sunset Cove and Rainbow Room

Rainbow Bay

Cindy

15. Cocodimama Small - Boutique Resort On Spectacular Beach 10 Bedroom Hotel Room

Governor's Harbour

16. Cocodimama Resort 14 Bedroom Hotel Room

Governor's Harbour

17. Boutique Resort on Spectacular Beach Available for Private Rental

Governors Harbour

Hannah R.

View all properties

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Sign in

Sign up, it's free

Top Middle Cay Hotel Reviews

Daddy Joes

10/10 Excellent

"Excellent hotel, my #1 pic in North Eleuthera"

The Cove Eleuthera

8/10 Good

"Hello, Having been to many Relais and Chateau properties through out the glove, my expectations were very high. I think The Cove did a great job overall for being in the Bahamas, however for this category of luxury resort, they fell short in many ways: They did not accomodate for an early check in, there were several power outages, internet and WiFi outages, there were water outages, the onsite water craft for excursions was not as clean as would be expected, there was a red ant infestation in our luxury bungalow which required sleeping in another suite for the night while fumigation took place. The staff was lovely, however, these issues need to be addressed."

Romora Bay Resort & Marina

10/10 Excellent

"The marina is very good the food at the restaurant was expensive but taste great We also have a sour experience at the from desk we asked for a water taxi to eluthera airport and they call fo a private taxi without tell us that was private when we got to the island they ask us to pay $70 for the ride that was 10 minutes and for the same ride before they charge us $10 each other than that the experience was nice the beach was very clean and beautiful 😍"

"Steps Away" 3-bedroom with free 6 seater golf cart, Kayak & Paddle board.

8/10 Good

"I recommend giving more info to the client sooner than 72 hours prior to arrival; or let clients know early on that they will get info 72 hours prior. Communications could be improved.Provide clients with transportation cost info and tipping info regarding getting from airport to the ferry and the ferry itself to the dock. The process for us was very confusing and Pinders didn't offer much clarity.The Steps Away house was very nice and well maintained and clean. Loved it.Once at the rental house all was quite nice. Oh, operating the TV was the pits - some instructions would help.Our cart was a bit of a concern, but was quickly repaired and no problems occurred.All in all, a good time was had by all, and the Steps Away is a great place."

Newly Remodeled Estate Directly on the Calm Caribbean w/Pool, Views

10/10 Excellent

"Tranquilville was the perfect getaway and location for our family vacation. It was exactly as described, but it was even better in-person (and the photos don't do it justice). The smaller of the 2 dwellings (closer to the firepit & water) was perfect for mom & dad, and gave us just a little space & time away from our 4 kids (ages 16-24) & granddaughter (1 year old). Both houses had everything we needed to cook meals, relax, do some necessary laundry, and enjoy Eleuthera. We especially loved enjoying the paddle board & 2-person kayak in front of the house, the small pool, & the provided beach towels got used daily as well. The owners & house manager were incredibly kind and accommodating (ie. our last-minute request for a pack-n-play, a late check-out, and a bowl of fresh mangoes provided upon our arrival were all very appreciated). We also loved that the airport was only a 10 minute drive, and it was also located close to the Blue Hole, Glass Window, Gaulding Cay, the grocery & liquor store, and everything our family needed for our vacation. We love Eleuthera for the perfect combination of relaxation & adventure, and would definitely stay here again!"

More cheap stays in Middle Cay

Royal Palm Hotel

Harbour Island Dunmore Town

$180 nightly

$198 total

Jul 29 - Jul 30

Total with taxes and fees

Hotels in Middle Cay with star-rating

Frequently asked questions

When is the best time to go to Middle Cay?

The best time to visit Middle Cay, North Eleuthera, for optimal weather and conditions, is generally from November to May.

During these months, you'll experience consistently pleasant temperatures, typically ranging from the mid-70s to low 80s Fahrenheit, with less humidity and a lower chance of rain. This period avoids the hotter, more humid summer months and the peak of hurricane season, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay for all travelers.

For couples seeking a tranquil and idyllic getaway, the shoulder months of November and May offer a superb balance of excellent weather and fewer crowds. You can enjoy the pristine beaches and water activities without feeling overwhelmed, making it ideal for a relaxed and intimate retreat.

Families traveling with children will find the months of December through April particularly appealing. The stable weather conditions are superb for outdoor activities like snorkeling, swimming, and exploring the island's natural beauty.

Can I cancel my hotel reservation on Expedia?

You can cancel your hotel reservation on Expedia, though it depends on the cancellation policy of your booking. Most bookings are refundable if canceled within 24-48 hours of the scheduled arrival. Be sure to check your booking confirmation for the exact cancellation policy. If free cancellation is available, you can cancel directly through your Expedia account by logging in, going to "My Trips", and selecting your reservation. To find flexible deals, filter your search by "Fully refundable property" for hotels in Middle Cay.

How much is the nightly rate at a Middle Cay hotel?

Prices for hotels in Middle Cay often vary, but you can find a great deal from $198 on Expedia. All sorts of factors affect price, such as the time of year or the days of the week you choose for your stay. Find the best deals by being flexible with your dates, and sort search results by "Price: low to high" for the cheapest rate.

Find hotels in Middle Cay from $198

Upfront pricing

Treat yourself

Be picky

Go beyond your typical stay in Middle Cay

Check prices for these dates

Filter by

Our top choices for Middle Cay hotels

1. Tingum Village Hotel

2. The Cove Eleuthera

3. Valentines Resort & Marina

4. Coral Sands Inn & Cottages

5. The Rock House Hotel

6. Eleven Bahama House

7. Royal Palm Hotel

8. Pink Sands Resort

9. Romora Bay Resort & Marina

10. Runaway Hill Inn

11. Daddy Joes

12. Spanish Wells Yacht Haven

13. Sky Beach Club

14. The Sunset Cove and Rainbow Room

15. Cocodimama Small - Boutique Resort On Spectacular Beach 10 Bedroom Hotel Room

16. Cocodimama Resort 14 Bedroom Hotel Room

17. Boutique Resort on Spectacular Beach Available for Private Rental

Top Middle Cay Hotel Reviews

Daddy Joes

More cheap stays in Middle Cay

Royal Palm Hotel

Hotels in Middle Cay with star-rating

Frequently asked questions

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Go further with the Expedia app