Find all hotels by Independent in Morristown, NY from $133

"The only complaint that I have is the beds were too hard and made my back ache."

"What a fabulous stay! The Sherman Inn was absolutely incredible - huge room (complete with Netflix on the TV), wonderful hosts, amazing breakfast, and the entire space so tastefully and historically maintained. We are now spoiled for all other hotels. Stay here - you'll love it!"

"Very clean and well kept and comfortable."

"I always enjoy staying at the Stonefence. They are upgrading the pool area so that wasn't available to swim in, but the beautiful river was! I hope that opening the restaurant will work out for them (they were doing a "soft opening" during the stay). I loved my lunch out on the patio, reading my book and seeing the river."

"Loved it, we will be back next year."

"Had an amazing time on the water. Rented a boat down the way and enjoyed the sunset every night from the back deck."

"Beautiful house with a great location on the lake. Seemed to be priced very well! And the owner was great to work with. Would recommend to anyone! "

"Very charming place with great views of the river area. Restaurant and bar area also excellent, great food and a very friendly staff. Quiet night, very peaceful!"

"The place was great! Location is was excellent, great sunrises and sunsets. Yes there's a marina bar downstairs, no it wasn't a problem, it was closed up by 8:30 each night and it was never rowdy. Whitney is a great host! There are definitely somethings that need a little work, but it wasn't a problem. One of the showers was out while we were there, but the other worked fine. Yes, the layout of the one shower is a little odd, but it works fine. It was very clean, there was no issues with odors. The air conditioning is a window unit, but was adequate - we were there the 2nd weekend in August, and it was the hottest weekend of the year, we were fine with it. It kept the living room cool during the day, and you open the windows and sliding glass doors at night. Yes, you have to climb stairs, but that's in the listing. The internet can be a little flaky (you're in a fairly remote place), but it worked well enough and we streamed movies in the evening no problem. I think some people have unrealistic expectations - this was a great visit and we wouldn't hesitate to stay there again. MUCH better than staying in even an upscale hotel."