Search Otter Creek Cottages

"This was genuinely the perfect place to fully disconnect and be present and have a good time. Carol & Dan were amazing hosts and I’m extremely grateful for them. I am definitely coming back here again! The property itself is awesome and the town is just so nice, if you love nature, you’ll love this place. I liked how there was a perfect distance away from stores, it makes each driving trip more intentional and fun"

"Great house had everything you could needClose to all, but very quiet "

"The place was so tidy and clean, plenty of amenities, toiletries, dishes, cooking utensils, etc. that made staying soooo comfy! Thank you. The beds were comfortable, the decor was sweet and cheerful. We would have preferred to be in the water, but Brantingham books up soooo fast. So this was the best alternative and so close to our family’s place on the lake, right down the road. Peter is an excellent communicator and was helpful and attentive when needed. Be aware that this is a very busy ATV/dirtbike road and can get pretty noisy! "

"The place was clean. Not very many things to do around. Couldnt really find any trails or anything, But overall was a nice quiet place. Definitely will be staying there again"

"Dan was extremely great to deal witj"

"love this place second time I stay here. I must say it's a family friends place so I'll just call them myself for my next stay,and save the fifty buck cleaning fee that the owner doesn't get. they pay their own cleaners. sorry VRBO. I will how ever use the service for many other stays but not this one."

"This home was so beautiful & cozy, perfectly located in Otter Lake, and the host was so accommodating and communicated clearly. Highly recommend! We loved the game selection, fireplace, and homemade sourdough bread. "

"This is our second stay at High Pines cabin, and it’s always a pleasure. Clean, comfortable, and quiet. We enjoy sitting on the screened in-porch, listening to the rooster crow, or the birds chirping or the river ever cruising by. Thendara and Old Forge are close and there are a few good golf courses not too far away."

"Clean, comfortable, as advertised! Beautiful home and property-great location——Relaxing & peaceful. Loved our stay!"