Find all hotels by Independent in Big Indian, NY from $161

"Would absolutely stay here again. Place was clean, the amenities were great and the staff was the best!"

"Great stay for a weekend out of the city. "

"Everything was great"

"Nice view! Calm place "

"My stay was wonderful but at some point at night was a dog barking when I was trying to fall asleep. "

"I had a wonderful winter escape at this Catskills hotel. The staff was truly stellar—kind, attentive, and incredibly helpful throughout my stay. The location was perfect for a peaceful reset, with quiet mountain views that felt worlds away from the city. The amenities were exactly what I needed to unwind and recharge. I left feeling refreshed and can’t wait to return."

"Clean cozy room, comfortable bed, great shower, inviting and beautifully decorated common areas, ability to have coffee any time, awesome breakfast, and last but definitely not least, the wonderful staff-genuinely warm and welcoming. And man, that breakfast was so good. I loved that I could have overnight oats for breakfast!"

"Can’t get enough of the grounds 4th time we been - Yousef "

"Disappointed about not having a jacuzzi when it was advertised, but everything else was excellent. "