Find all hotels by Independent in Star Lake, NY from $300

"Very peaceful and private with easy access to the cabin. Had split wood on deck and back up on site. The owners are super nice. The only down side, we might have missed was we needed to bring our own bed sheets. Other than that everything was amazing!"

"Boyd Pond was the destination for our most recent sister getaway. This cabin was incredibly welcoming and CLEAN! We did not bring our pets with us but it was so wonderful to see how pet-friendly the rental was...food/water dishes, poo bags, leashes, etc. The kitchen with stocked with everything we needed and more. Beds were comfortable and we stayed nice and warm throughout our snowy stay. Our host was gracious and responsive which is always a plus! We would not hesitate to book a repeat stay. "

"This cozy cottage sits on a beautiful pond. Highly recommend to anyone who wants to unplug from life and enjoy nature."

"The radiant floor heat and outdoor fire pit made for a cozy October stay! Was able to fully relax and enjoy our stay. "

"Nice place in a very friendly neighborhood. The lake is beautiful and I even caught a nice largemouth bass right off the dock. Good hiking with great views nearby also. "

"The location is very convenient for hiking and trails nearby. The hosts are always very accommodating and responsive. The house is always very clean and well-kept. We’ve stayed several times and will continue to in the future. "

"Beautiful views out back"

"We really enjoyed our stay — the house was beautiful, spotless, and well maintained. The view was stunning, and we loved all of the activities available nearby. It was a great place to relax and unwind.The host was fantastic. He responded very quickly and kindly accommodated both an early check in, and late check out for us at no additional cost. The only downside was that the loose dog from the neighboring cabin kept coming onto our property throughout the stay and reacting negatively towards us. We were traveling with our two dogs, and it created a few uncomfortable moments where we had to leave the area quickly to avoid any negative interactions. It would be helpful if the neighboring property secured their dog to ensure all guests (and pets) can enjoy the space peacefully.Overall, it’s a wonderful home in a gorgeous location — we just hope this small issue is addressed for future guests."

"The cabin was comfortable and felt like home. Very much enjoyed the area and night sky."