Long Island Historic Hotels from $1,125 - Fully Refundable Options

Top Cities in Long Island

A coastal landscape with clear turquoise waters, a sandy beach, and lush greenery.

Check availability on Long Island Historic Hotels

Tonight

Tomorrow

Next weekend

In two weeks

Our top choices for Long Island historic hotels

1. Gems at Paradise Beach Hotel

Clarence Town

David

Private beach, free beach shuttle, free beach cabanas, sun loungers

2. Stella Maris Resort Club

Stella Maris

Kimberly

$1,019 nightly

Sep 29 - Sep 30

Total with taxes and fees

3. Cape Santa Maria Beach Resort

Galliot Cay

Ronald

View all properties

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Sign in

Sign up, it's free

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

BEACH FRONT HOME WITH DOCK AND BEACH. Blue hole and sandbar nearby.

10/10 Excellent

"Wow! What a beautiful place!! We loved every moment. Easy check in and great communication In fact, they go above and beyond for you!! Jack and Kay were amazing. There isn’t anything negative we have to say!! Shipwreck had everything we needed. Coffee k-cups, filtered water, air conditioning, and all the kitchen utensils to kayaks!! Jack and Kay communicated very well and were responsive (within minutes). Kay, thank you so very much . You went above and beyond. We will be back and we will let others know about your place!! Until next time."

HGTV-Featured Beachfront Villa / Steps to Sand / Resort Amenities Included

10/10 Excellent

"Location was amazing, host always available, little extras plentiful. A very good experience…one you share with others. Not even home yet and a friend wants contact information based on my FB posts. We’ll be back!"

OCEAN FRONT HOME WITH POOL,DOCK-STEPS TO MORIAH NATIONAL PARK

10/10 Excellent

"The house was stunning! The views were incredible, very well stocked kitchen and grill area. The AC worked great in a very hot month! We loved having access to all the kayaks and the house being right on the water just made it the best vacation ever!!!!"

Harbor Breeze Villas

10/10 Excellent

"Stayed in one of the villas for 4 nights. The villa is well equipped with everything you need. Ate at the restaurant twice, excellent service and the food was good. There is a store as well where you can purchase some goods which is convenient. Pool was clean and the area was very peaceful with a gorgeous view. There is also a private beach that you can walk to (clear path) from your villa. Pristine water and quiet (except for the cicadas singing). There is an elevated cabana which lounge chairs overlooking the beach where you can relax. Would definitely stay here again if Im ever in Long Island. Only downside was the bigs, which is expected. The villa is surround by plenty of trees/plants. Luckily there was bug spray in the villa. So I was able to spray out the villa and that toom care of most of the bugs."

Great Location, beautiful home on the water,beach, pool and top amenities

10/10 Excellent

"The property and home were exactly as pictured and described. There was so much to do at the house with the pool, dock, kayaks and paddle boards, huge screened in porch, and beachfront for our family with 2 teenagers. Communication prior to our trip, as well as while we were there, was very attentive and helpful regarding the home, activities and restaurants on the island, making sure we’re were happy with our stay. They were even able to have the house stocked with all of our groceries and drinks the day of our arrival.If we are able to come back to vacation in beautiful Exuma (which I hope we do) we would absolutely stay at Jack’s Island House again!"

Ocean Front Property With Pool. - George Town

10/10 Excellent

"This is our 2nd stay and we love SeaBreeze lodge. The view is amazing!!! This side of the island makes great use of the kayaks and paddleboards. You can kayak to a little island during high tide. You can walk out in the middle of the flats during low tide. You can get a float and enjoy the calm water. You can kayak right to a blue hole. The roads are a little rough to get to the house but rent an SUV and go slower and you will be completely fine. We had everything to cook meals and there is a grill for use as well. The pool is wonderful to have as well. The outside area is so relaxing. The host and Joanes are extremely responsive and helpful with whatever questions or needs arise. We love it here and will be back. Thank you for a wonderful week stay in Exuma."

Pool, Beach, kayaks, great snorkeling, calm side of the island,

10/10 Excellent

"We were met by the Kay and she had stocked our refrigerator with all the things requested. The house was the perfect size for our family of four. The access to the beach was wonderful and we took advantage of the kayaks provided as well. Jack was great at answering all of my questions….and trust me I had a lot. He gave great suggestions and resources to help the trip to so smoothly! It is truly a piece of paradise and I would definitely stay there again!!"

Room 1

Upfront pricing

Treat yourself

Be picky

Top Cities in Long Island

Clarence Town

Check availability on Long Island Historic Hotels

Our top choices for Long Island historic hotels

1. Gems at Paradise Beach Hotel

2. Stella Maris Resort Club

3. Cape Santa Maria Beach Resort

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

BEACH FRONT HOME WITH DOCK AND BEACH. Blue hole and sandbar nearby.

HGTV-Featured Beachfront Villa / Steps to Sand / Resort Amenities Included

OCEAN FRONT HOME WITH POOL,DOCK-STEPS TO MORIAH NATIONAL PARK

Harbor Breeze Villas

Great Location, beautiful home on the water,beach, pool and top amenities

Beachside Exuma Villa newly remodeled!Great location near resorts & restaurants

Ocean Front Property With Pool. - George Town

Pool, Beach, kayaks, great snorkeling, calm side of the island,

Oceanfront Villa steps away from the ocean- Featured on HGTV Bahamas Life

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Historic Hotels in Long Island from $1,125

Upfront pricing

Treat yourself

Be picky

Top Cities in Long Island

Clarence Town

Check availability on Long Island Historic Hotels

Our top choices for Long Island historic hotels

1. Gems at Paradise Beach Hotel

2. Stella Maris Resort Club

3. Cape Santa Maria Beach Resort

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

BEACH FRONT HOME WITH DOCK AND BEACH. Blue hole and sandbar nearby.

Explore a world of travel with Expedia