9.6/10 Exceptional! (127 reviews)
Beautiful island, but a disappointing experience
Toberua Island itself is stunning, but for the price, our stay fell well short.
We were given a "complimentary upgrade" on arrival, only to learn the previous guests had asked to leave that room because of constant strong winds. The other side of the island was calm and sunny. We were told we'd have to wait until Monday to move back to our booked room, and only got it after pushing. It felt like we'd been moved to the worse location under the guise of an upgrade.
Dietary needs were a bigger problem. We'd told the resort months ahead that my partner needed gluten-free food and were assured it was fine. Yet on night one she was served regular bread, then battered onion rings, then a chocolate cake a waitress confirmed was gluten-free, until another rushed over to say it contained gluten. We had to question every meal after that, and one serving of gluten-free bread was stale and inedible. Food quality was inconsistent overall.
Management's response was just an apology with no follow-up actions or reassurance so the food errors continued, and the relief managers were largely absent and unbothered.
The desalination system was down, yet we received only three bottles of water before having to buy our own. Some costs were covered only after we raised it.
Some staff were fantastic and the island is wonderful, but I'd struggle to recommend Toberua without major improvements to food service and management.
Reviewed on Nov 9, 2026