We had a wonderful time. Having lived in the keys before I know to expect Palmetto bugs, a.k.a. roaches, and stinky seaweed. Those are things that owners really cannot control. To get five stars, I would say the place would have to be immaculate. The furniture is scarred, The refrigerator was extremely dented and the ice maker never worked. The doors in both the house and the guest house were very hard to open and close. Lightbulbs were burnt out. Screws missing in ceiling fans. I still give it 4 stars because it was in a great area, the sunrises were breathtaking, and it accommodated to all of our needs.