Find all hotels by Independent in Bakers Mills, NY from $138

"We enjoyed our stay! Very clean and cozy. Very quiet neighborhood and beautiful views of the mountains!! Host was excellent! Thank you!!"

"Incredible hospitality, great cabin vibes, awesome amenities"

"Staff was super friendly, even remembering us (or more likely our dog!). Room was very clean, bathroom looked like it had been recently updated. (Previous stays had very tired looking bathroom.) Coffee and breakfast bar was actually ready at 6, unlike at other hotels. Coffee was rather good! And actual Half n Half pods were available. Oh, and bonus: they now provide poop bags for picking up after your fur baby. Nice touch! If you go, ask for Rebel, behind the desk. A happy, sweet capuccino colored pitty who wobbles but doesn't fall down (usually), due to a neurological condition. He's a great welcoming comittee of one!"

"Room and staff wonderful "

"Absolutely great property! The hosts were very responsive and it was easily the most stocked VRBO kitchen I ever stayed in."

"Great house! Our family had a Pre-Thanksgiving weekend together and had a wonderful time. Lots of space and things to do at the house. It was a wonderful experience!!"

"Just what we needed for sweet and cozy weekend getaway! The cabin is charming, clean and exactly what you need for an unplugged, woodsy experience! The hot tub is an absolute MUST!"

"Motel wasnt the most beautiful. The tiles in the bathroom needed replaceing - the thermostat had a note on it to use the mini split instead, it smelled of smoke and years gone by , but you cant beat the "mind your own business" vibe, the location, and the overall odd charm. "

"Beautiful cabin. Well equipped. Comfy and cozy"