Find hotels near Bay Street Theatre, Sag Harbor from $132

Discover the top-rated hotels near Bay Street Theatre that promise a delightful stay in Sag Harbor, New York.Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round SpaLuxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round Spa stands out with a perfect review rating of 10 and is located just 3.3 miles from Bay Street Theatre. This exquisite retreat features an outdoor heated pool and a private chef service, making it an exceptional choice for travelers seeking relaxation and luxury. Guests can unwind in the hot tub or explore nearby windsurfing and kayaking opportunities. The hotel also offers a sauna and a fully equipped kitchen for added convenience.Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay!Rated 10 by travelers, Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay! is situated 4.4 miles from Bay Street Theatre. This elegant estate features a heated pool and a stunning beach view, providing a perfect backdrop for relaxation. Guests can enjoy amenities such as a jetted bathtub, private parking, and opportunities for paddleboating and golfing nearby. The hotel's spacious kitchen and patio area enhance the appeal for those looking to enjoy a home-like experience while away.Room 1 queen bed on waterfront + bikes and kayaksRoom 1 queen bed on waterfront + bikes and kayaks is an inviting option located just a 14-minute walk from Bay Street Theatre, a review rating of 10. This charming room offers air conditioning and a sofa bed, making it a cozy spot for travelers. Guests can take advantage of complimentary bikes and kayaks for a delightful day exploring the waterfront and nearby attractions.

Discover the perfect stay near the Bay Street Theatre, featuring top-rated accommodations that offer unique experiences.Room 1 queen bed on waterfront + bikes and kayaksRoom 1 queen bed on waterfront + bikes and kayaks is a charming retreat located just a 14-minute walk from Bay Street Theatre. With an impeccable review rating of 10, this hotel offers air conditioning for comfort and a cozy sofa bed for relaxation. Guests can also enjoy complimentary bikes and kayaks, making it easy to explore the scenic surroundings.sunset bikes and kayaks in the villagesunset bikes and kayaks in the village is another exceptional option, also a 14-minute stroll from Bay Street Theatre. Rated 10 by travelers, this hotel features air conditioning to ensure a pleasant stay. Guests will appreciate the opportunity to explore the village on bikes, enhancing their overall experience.Room3, best waterfront view +shared bath, bikes+kayaksRoom3, best waterfront view +shared bath, bikes+kayaks offers stunning waterfront views and is conveniently located 14 minutes from Bay Street Theatre. With a perfect review rating of 10, this hotel provides air conditioning for comfort and the chance to enjoy shared facilities. Guests can take advantage of available bikes and kayaks to fully embrace the beautiful Sag Harbor landscape.

For families seeking top-rated, family-friendly hotels near Bay Street Theatre, Sag Harbor offers some excellent options that combine comfort with fun activities for the kids.Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round SpaLuxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round Spa is located only 3.3 miles from Bay Street Theatre and boasts a stellar review rating of 10. This expansive hotel is tailored for families with features like a high chair for children and an arcade game room. Additional amenities include a heated pool, hot tub, and access to water sports, making it a fantastic choice for family fun and relaxation.Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay!Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay! is an inviting retreat just 4.4 miles from Bay Street Theatre. With a perfect review rating of 10, this hotel is ideal for families, featuring amenities like a foosball table, toys for children, and a secured yard. Guests will also enjoy the heated pool, a fully-equipped kitchen, and nearby paddle boating opportunities, ensuring a memorable stay for all ages.Topping Rose HouseTopping Rose House, situated 4.8 miles from Bay Street Theatre, is a charming 4.5-star hotel rated 9.2 by travelers. It offers family-friendly amenities, including cribs, babysitting services, and a beautiful garden. Guests can also take advantage of the on-site spa, outdoor pool, and the delightful rooftop terrace, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay for families.

Discover the best hotels with stunning views near Bay Street Theatre, perfect for travelers seeking a top-rated stay in Sag Harbor.Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay!With an outstanding review rating of 10, this hotel is located just 4.4 miles from Bay Street Theatre. Guests will appreciate the beautiful beach views from the patio and the private heated pool, perfect for relaxation. The estate features a spacious kitchen with modern appliances, ideal for preparing meals after a day of exploring. Additional amenities include onsite parking and access to nearby paddleboating, making it an excellent choice for those looking to enjoy the outdoors.

For travelers looking for affordable and family-friendly options near Bay Street Theatre, these hotels offer great amenities and easy access to the area.Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round SpaJust 3.3 miles from Bay Street Theatre, this stunning 10-star retreat is perfect for families seeking a spacious getaway. Guests can enjoy a heated pool, outdoor patio, and a private chef service, ensuring a memorable stay. With a perfect review rating of 10, this hotel also features high-speed WiFi, a sauna, and nearby opportunities for water sports and hiking.Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay!Located only 4.4 miles from Bay Street Theatre, this 10-star estate is an ideal family-friendly choice. With amenities including a heated pool, onsite golf, and a large kitchen, it offers plenty of space for family activities. The hotel boasts a perfect review rating of 10 and includes options for paddleboating, hiking, and nearby shopping for travelers to explore.Room 1 queen bed on waterfront + bikes and kayaksThis charming room is just a 14-minute walk from Bay Street Theatre, providing travelers with a cozy waterfront stay. Rated 10 by travelers, this accommodation features a queen bed along with complimentary bikes and kayaks to explore the scenic surroundings. With air conditioning and a sofa bed, it's a perfect spot for a relaxing getaway.

For those seeking a refreshing escape near Bay Street Theatre, check out these top-rated hotels with pools that promise a delightful stay in Sag Harbor.Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round SpaJust 3.3 miles from Bay Street Theatre, this luxurious retreat boasts a perfect review rating of 10. Guests can enjoy an outdoor heated pool, and for added privacy, there's also a private in-room pool option. This hotel offers a wealth of amenities including a hot tub, fitness facilities, and nearby activities like windsurfing and kayaking, ensuring a memorable stay.Private Rustic Lodge on 3.5 acres - Ideal for relaxing and the HolidaysLocated 4.7 miles from Bay Street Theatre, this charming lodge features an outdoor pool and a secure in-room private pool for ultimate relaxation. With a review rating of 9.8, travelers can unwind in a picturesque setting that includes amenities like a patio, kitchen facilities, and access to nearby beaches and wineries, perfect for a peaceful retreat.New and Modern Bridgehampton AccommodationsThis modern accommodation is just 3.4 miles from Bay Street Theatre and holds a solid review rating of 9.4. Guests can take advantage of the shared heated outdoor pool, along with convenient amenities such as on-site parking, a hot tub, and nearby local beaches and shopping. Ideal for both relaxation and exploration, this hotel is a fantastic choice for a getaway.

Searching for the best pet-friendly hotels near Bay Street Theatre? Discover top-rated options that welcome both you and your furry friends with open arms.Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round SpaLuxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round Spa is a stunning getaway located just 3.3 miles from Bay Street Theatre, with a perfect review rating of 10. This pet-friendly retreat welcomes dogs and offers fantastic amenities, including a heated pool, hot tub, and on-site tennis. Guests can enjoy outdoor dining on the patio, and a private chef is available for an exquisite dining experience.Private Rustic Lodge on 3.5 acres - Ideal for relaxing and the HolidaysPrivate Rustic Lodge on 3.5 acres is a charming and serene option situated 4.7 miles from Bay Street Theatre, with an impressive review rating of 9.8. It welcomes pets and features an outdoor pool, perfect for relaxation. Guests can indulge in nearby paddle boating, explore local wineries, or enjoy hiking and biking trails, making it an ideal retreat for nature lovers.A Room At The BeachA Room At The Beach is a cozy 3-star hotel located 4.9 miles from Bay Street Theatre, with a great traveler rating score of 9.0. This pet-friendly hotel accommodates dogs and offers a lovely outdoor pool, a terrace for relaxation, and easy access to the nearby beach. Guests can take advantage of complimentary bicycles for exploring and enjoy the convenience of self-parking.

To look for discounts on hotels near Bay Street Theatre, join One Key™—our free travel rewards program. One Key members always get our best prices and earn OneKeyCash™* on eligible bookings for every dollar spent. Another way to save is by bundling your hotel and flights together on Expedia.*Excludes taxes and fees. OneKeyCash is not redeemable for cash and can only be used on Expedia and other participating brands.