Search Modest Town Cottages

Change your mind

Book hotels with free cancellation

Treat yourself

Save instantly and earn perks with One Key

Learn about One Key

Be picky

Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Compare 67 Cottages in Modest Town with updated reviews, rates, and availability.

"The view was wonderful. The people were friendly property was very welcoming and great."

includes taxes & fees

$179 per night

May 1 - May 2

1 bedroom, iron/ironing board, free WiFi, bed sheets

"Loved it. It was clean and just a lovely quaint cabin. Just enough for us to enjoy each others company. Would recommend this place to my other friends and family. Thank you to the wonderful host for a beautiful Christmas with our kids! "

"Convenient location! Exactly as advertised!"

"The Salty Sailor was an excellent, affordable, and pet friendly rental. Nice location on ridge rd next to Mr Baldys which is a must to try if you stay here. The rooms are a bit older but maintained well. I didn’t experience any of the conditions that were listed in the other reviews here. We would certainly stay here again."

"Stayed here to explore the area and do a tour to see ponies."

includes taxes & fees

$344 per night

May 1 - May 2

"Very cozy cottage tucked off the road great check-in experience place was clean easy parking will definitely go back again"

"Exactly as listed, had a very pleasant stay and would definitely return! "

"This quaint treasure was amazingly friendly, very clean, perfect for a relaxing vaca. We had an awesome time and an incredible experience "

"I had stayed at this property in the past and was really glad to get to stay again. It is clean, quiet, and close to the town center of Onancock. Really looking forward to returning!"

"The cottage was perfect and the hosts are great communicators. It was cozy and all updated, my kids loved it and asked when we're going back. "

"Cozy and clean cottage with all the amenities. Close to everything!"

"Stayed here with a group of friends. 6 of us in total, plenty of room. Great house, great location, reasonably priced!"

"Vacation very enjoyable and peaceful"

"Our stay could not have been better. The host and the property were 1st class. A beautiful quiet location. If we are in that area again we would hope this property would be available. "

"Great location close to main road but quiet and removed from the busy tourist area of the island. Clean property with all the necessities. Quick and easy communication with property manager.."

"We stayed here for several days during Pony Penning Week. The cottage is small, but cute, comfortable, and well appointed. We had a minor plumbing issue on day 2, and our host responded immediately and rectified the problem with no interruption to our plans. AC units in each room kept us cool, despite hot, muggy weather. You'll want bug spray; the mosquitoes are fierce at dawn and dusk. (The island is on a salt marsh after all.) The cottage location is convenient to plenty of restaurants, shops,...

"Perfect place for a weekend getaway. A peaceful little efficiency close to town but far enough off the beaten path for a great escape!"

"A nice house with a great location, easy to get to everything on the island. Having a playground across the street was extremely helpful with two small kids. Only critique was that the twin mattress were slippery enough that my kids fell out of bed. They are both on twin beds at home and we were suprised that was an issue. Other than that great!"