Top Hotels Near Old House Museum in Cutchogue

"Great location. Property owner was very responsive. We had an amazing stay!"

"This B&B, and its hosts, were simply amazing. I cannot recommend this place enough."

"We were in the area for a wedding and the Barnes’ home was perfect for our family. Lots of room to spread out, immaculately clean, beautiful pool area, short walk down to the small beach area. Close to lots of wineries and adorable village of Mattituck. The communication with the hosts was great and they were extremely responsive. A great place to stay if you are visiting the area! "

"The host was amazing and super responsive. Great location and very easy check-in/checkout. "

"Andrew had thought of everything from the point of view of the traveler from instructions, cleanliness, amenities, and comfort. His communication skills are top rated as is his aesthetic design style of the home. The home truly tells a story that you should pause and read as you are heading out to the terrace or a dip in the hot tub. Sitting by the fire is so relaxing and Andrew was there to answer questions. All basic things are provided the one thing we missed was a tea kettle. "

"Kates house was very clean with a well-stocked and equipped kitchen, comfortable beds, and close to the beach, the bay, and all of the North Fork. That means, in September, fantastic corn and tomatoes, beautiful beaches, and a lot of memories for my mom, who was on a bit of a memory tour. Kate also provided many useful suggestions for local restaurants and attractions, which were helpful. Only one bathroom, but if that works for you three comfortable bedrooms in a lovely spot."

"Loved the house and the location. Walking distance to the beach and a few minutes from a bunch of vineyards. Would highly recommend this one to everyone!"

"What a fantastic weekend at Whitecap! From the moment we arrived, we knew we had found a special place. The photos don't do it justice—the home is perfectly kept and maintained. You can tell the owners pour so much love and care into it, with everything from the sparkling clean floors to the crisp linens being immaculate. It honestly felt like we were the first guests to ever stay there. The property's upkeep was truly impressive, with everything in working order and a clear focus on regular upkeep.The attention to detail was incredible. The kitchen was stocked with all the essentials, and every room was decorated with a warm, inviting touch that made it so easy to settle in. And the location is unbeatable, with the beach just a short, five-minute walk away. We loved being able to easily pop over to the sand whenever we wanted.The weekend was pure bliss. We spent our time relaxing in the well appointed rooms, sipping coffee on the patio, and just enjoying the quiet escape. It was the perfect little getaway, and we’re already dreaming about our next trip back.Our host's graciousness was the cherry on top. Their communication was easy and friendly, and they went above and beyond to make sure we felt right at home. It's rare to find someone so genuinely kind and accommodating, and their hospitality truly made our stay unforgettable. We are so grateful for their generosity and for sharing their vision with us."

"Our family had a wonderful vacation at this property. The house was lovely and accommodated our whole family easily. The host was very helpful and easy to work with."