Book Fly Creek Bed & Breakfast

"Remotely located on a beautiful lake a few miles from Cooperstown. Everything was very nice and clean. The staff was particularly attentive here, I would definitely recommend this lodge to friends and would stay here again."

"I loved the historical nature of he property and the cozy room. The host was friendly and welcoming and his family was charming. I felt at ease in the space making it a much better experience than a chain hotel. The breakfasts were terrific!!"

"A great find. A beautiful old building and well kept interior with appropriate upgrades in bathroom. Very comfy bed and pillows, quiet and friendly. Fun evening at the restaurant across the street with the locals. Will make it a point to stay here when next in the area! "

"Beautiful B&B! Friendly staff, comfy and unique room and delicious breakfast. Easy walking distance to Baseball HOF, restaurants and shopping."

"We stayed at the companion property the Stone Mill Inn and it was great. "

"Well cared for and pride of ownership. Breakfast was delicious. "

"The place was very clean and the host was very nice. "

"Loved staying at David’s home. The location is perfect and the kindness and friendliness of the host was welcoming. I didn’t realize it was a shared bath but that was not a problem since I was the only one there. Perhaps I missed that in the listing. Brought back many memories for me when I lived at the lake during the summer."

"The hosts couldn't have been more welcoming. The breakfast absolutely incredible! Such a home away from home!!"

"I stayed here while my son played in the Cooperstown baseball tournament. David was so helpful and friendly, and treated me like family. The view was stunning; I will miss having coffee on the deck overlooking the lake as well as David's amazing breakfasts. Oh, and his cookies were to die for! :)"

"We checked in on our own for just 10 minutes and left this place. Nobody present to welcome us. No wifi and or internet, all fridges were unplugged. Web everywhere. Trees overgrown on hot tub and pool and many more! "

"We came in for the Baseball Hall of Fame Induction Weekend (about 40min away) and stayed at this B&B. The owners are incredibly hospitable, breakfast is great, and the historic home setting is good as well. The drive to Cooperstown is through some gorgeous and serene countryside settings."

"We had a great experience."

"Having been born and raised in this area, I wasn't familiar with this location when trying to find a place close to family when coming back to visit. The address said Fort Plain, however it's in town of Danube, outside of St. Johnsville, not even remotely close to FP. Mind the location, as that wasn't a big deal to travel back and forth. The problem came from the fact that nothing had been cleaned in quite some time. When I entered the B&B it was pitch black and I wasn't sure I was even in the...

"Pros: Valerie is a kind host, and the property is in one of the most beautiful areas I have ever stayed. Cons: There is one shared bathroom on the first floor. There is no bathroom in the room, or the one next door which I saw when I found out that the dividing door was not locked. The pillows did not have liners in the pillow cases and were stained so we did not use them. The sheets had other people's hair on them, so we didn't use the cover sheets or blankets. The part of the house we stayed...

"While the rooms and furnishings are very nice, the bathrooms we not cleanly or updated. The night I stayed there, the power had gone off and there was no air conditioning and the no water. This could be a nice B&B but the outdoors need to be improved. For starters, they could remove the junk water heater from the front porch."

"I've traveled around the world, and this is by far the place I've ever stayed! The accommodations were very clean and impressive. The gourmet meals they prepared for breakfast and dinner were always delicious. The staff were helpful and friendly, and the gracious owner went out of his way to make sure we had everything we needed and more. We were thrilled that our daughter was able to take her first horseback riding lesson there. Our kids loved holding the baby goats that were born there that...

"House was exactly as described. Super spacious, well designed, and the big room where everyone can be together was very special was perfect for a group reunion. There were a ton of fun activities and beautiful spots in Cooperstown very close to the house. The host went way above and beyond. They were extremely interesting and interested in understanding our groups needs. Super quick response times. They provided a spreadsheet of recommendations for different activities and grocery...

"Great location in the center of Cooperstown. Everything within easy walking distance. Large room, ample parking. Easy check in and check out"

"This was perfect for us to stay after the game at Double day Field, it was clean, affordable and we could walk to get some dinner and breakfast."