Commons Historic District Vacations from $728

Second time here. Disappointed that the only brunch options were a few things on the menu--we'd thought it was Mothers Day brunch --but the menu, overall, was solid, and intriguing. Good variety of choices for various levels of appetite and various tastes-pasta, meats, salads, fish, sides, sandwiches. Our meals were very very good! The 4 of us agreed the sticky rice appetizer was the best we'd ever had. Sushi was also very good- fresh and tasty. Filet was done perfectly. Honestly don't remember what else everyone had, but we all really enjoyed our food. Sides were also excellent. Asparagus was cooked properly-still green, a tiny bit of crunch. Truffle tater tots were one of my favorite things I've eaten in a long time, and I don't even love truffle. Mild flavor,& crispy. Delicious. Cocktails were well-done. Coffee was kind of gross---super-weak. The after-meal espresso, tho, was excellent -strong and frothy. We don't do dessert often, but we made a great choice ordering here. The chocolate gelato was honestly some of the best we'd ever eaten. The little donut dessert-served on a cute "Ferris wheel-" type server, was AMAZING. Love the view from inside as well, from almost every seat in the place. Bathrooms were clean and well-stocked, even through a very busy Mothers Day rush. Staff, from check-in to exit, was professional and friendly, and professional-looking.

Customer Service is outstanding

Friendly staff, good coffee nearby and a restaurant next to the place. We will be staying again.

We love 1Hotel. This was our fourth visit. However, this visit was different. From the loud music playing until two oclock in the morning, to the garbage left behind outside the entrance to the nightclub, the vibe was not at all what we experienced previously during our trips to Brooklyn. We sincerely hope the decision to use the upstairs floor as a nightclub is reconsidered. Being kept awake by loud music is not acceptable. Also, there was a bag of trash sitting on top of the trashcan for two days.Such a shame for this beautiful hotel. Attention to detail is what made this hotel so special.

Good size room and clean. A/C worked wonderfully as did blackout curtains. Bed and pillows comfy. Was worried about outside noise due to Times Square location but it was a non issue. Bell hops were friendly and timely with bags. Some small negatives: bathroom frosted glass door shines bright light into room at night (if not staying alone) and no fan; pretty noisy from neighbors and doors slamming (glad I had ear plugs); was surprised at check-in they needed multiple ids and cc swiped twice.