Find all hotels by Independent in Edgartown, MA from $85

"Cleaning, staff, Heat"

"Great to have a hotel nearby when the boats are cancelled. Patrick is a great host"

"Friendly staff, clean room (housekeeping did an awesome job!), convenient parking, great location - walking distance to cafes, shops, restaurants, waterfront, etc, easy check-in/out. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!"

"Our stay at The Mansion Inn was nothing short of fabulous. The décor strikes that perfect balance between historic charm and modern chic — every corner feels thoughtfully designed. Our room was impeccable, the bedding unbelievably soft, and the whole experience exuded quiet luxury without pretension. The staff deserves special mention — warm, attentive, and genuinely eager to make your stay seamless. One note for future guests: parking can be tight on busy days. There is a lot, but it’s best to drop your luggage first; the team is more than happy to help you with the process. We left feeling rested, spoiled, and already planning our return. The Mansion Inn captures everything that makes Martha’s Vineyard so special — timeless elegance, effortless comfort, and a touch of magic."

"We were greeted warmly and the hotel had everything we needed. Centrally located with a number of walkable attractions and amenities."

"Good"

"The room were clean. The staff were all friendly! I will definitely go back!!! "

"Great staff. Friendly , beautiful hotel , scenic views and wrap around porch."

"Great room, nice view, perfect location. Power did go out one night, coffee machine never worked and they had no fix, and the breakfast is obscenely expensive."