Carp Lake Vacations from $956

It was the little touches from the personalized note to wonderful selections of beverages and snacks in my room. The dinner menu, though brief, had variety. I had a new item, ricotta on sour dough toast.........it was delicious. The staff were very friendly and attentive, I will be sure to recommend.

I typically don’t go beyond giving the basic reviews, but felt compelled to write a detailed review based on the exceptional support I received from one of the Rock Star staff members Ellie. So glad that we chose to stay at the Island House Hotel over the Father’s Day weekend. It’s a beautiful property pretty close to Main Street and enough distance away from the tourist activities. Here is the best part of our experience…when we checked out, my daughter left her phone in the room. We didn’t realize until after took a ferry out of island. You can imagine a teenage daughter’s reaction 🙂. When we called the hotel, Ellie not only immediately located the phone but also arranged for the phone to be send on the next ferry departing in about 15 mins. We had the phone in our hands in about 45 mins from the phone call. I know for a fact that such customer excellence is rare to find and hence my obligation to recognize Ellie. Thank you Ellie for what you do in maximizing the experience and lifelong memories for families.

Compact with everything we needed (but no shampoo or shower gel). Only a 10 minute walk from the ferry terminal which is a big plus (no parking worries). Our only negative was the loud noise of the fridge compressor overnight.

What a beautiful, well maintained and wonderfully staffed inn! All amenities were incredible! We were so very pleased with our stay!

The stay is literally across the street from where the ferry drops you off if you take Shepler's Ferry. Your bags are brought to your room. The hotel is beautiful, well-kept and the staff is professional and friendly. My only complaint is that $1,500 for two nights and no view of anything.....literally no windows in the rooms if you are placed in the atrium section of the hotel.