A sunset over a beach with rocks in the foreground and a sailboat in the distance.

$48 Cheap Flights to Plum Island, NJ

View $48 flight on Tue, Jan 12, 2027

Photo by Tray

Popular airlines

  • Be in the know

    Get alerts if flight prices drop or rise*

  • Book smarter

    Save up to 30% on select hotels after you book a flight*

  • Earn twice

    Earn your airline miles on top of our OneKeyCash

    Learn about One Key

  • Fly smart with our great value deals

    Expedia compares millions of flights to find the best value deals for where you want to go.

    Nonstop

    Carry-on included

    Lower price than typical

    Show more deals

    How much is the cheapest flight to Plum Island?

    Prices were available within the past 7 days and start at $48 for one-way flights and $88 for roundtrip, for the period specified. Prices and availability are subject to change.

    All deals

    One way

    Roundtrip

    Select Frontier Airlines flight, departing Sat, Jan 16 from Columbus to New York, returning Sat, Jan 23, priced at $220 Found 3 hours ago

    Sat, Jan 16 - Sat, Jan 23 · CMH · LGA · Roundtrip

    Select Frontier Airlines flight, departing Sat, Jan 16 from Columbus to New York, returning Sat, Jan 23, priced at $220 Found 3 hours ago

    Sat, Jan 16 - Sat, Jan 23 · CMH · EWR · Roundtrip

    Select Frontier Airlines flight, departing Tue, Dec 8 from Columbus to New York, returning Thu, Dec 10, priced at $235 Found 4 hours ago

    Tue, Dec 8 - Thu, Dec 10 · CMH · EWR · Roundtrip

    Select Frontier Airlines flight, departing Thu, Jan 21 from Columbus to New York, returning Sat, Jan 23, priced at $240 Found 4 hours ago

    Thu, Jan 21 - Sat, Jan 23 · CMH · EWR · Roundtrip

    Select Frontier Airlines flight, departing Tue, Dec 1 from Columbus to New York, returning Thu, Dec 3, priced at $242 Found 1 hour ago

    Tue, Dec 1 - Thu, Dec 3 · CMH · EWR · Roundtrip

    Select Frontier Airlines flight, departing Thu, Feb 4 from Columbus to New York, returning Thu, Feb 18, priced at $245 Found 12 hours ago

    Thu, Feb 4 - Thu, Feb 18 · CMH · EWR · Roundtrip

    Select American Airlines flight, departing Mon, Jan 18 from Columbus to New York, returning Mon, Jan 18, priced at $246 Found 1 day ago

    Mon, Jan 18 - Mon, Jan 18 · CMH · JFK · Roundtrip

    Select United flight, departing Tue, Jan 19 from Columbus to New York, returning Sat, Jan 23, priced at $279 Just found

    Tue, Jan 19 - Sat, Jan 23 · CMH · EWR · Roundtrip

    Select Delta flight, departing Tue, Jan 5 from Columbus to New York, returning Tue, Jan 12, priced at $337 Found 1 hour ago

    Tue, Jan 5 - Tue, Jan 12 · CMH · LGA · Roundtrip

    Select Southwest Airlines flight, departing Tue, Jan 5 from Columbus to New York, returning Tue, Jan 12, priced at $357 Found 1 hour ago

    Tue, Jan 5 - Tue, Jan 12 · CMH · LGA · Roundtrip

    Alternative airports

    Prices were available within the past 7 days. Prices and availability are subject to change.

    Select flight to John F. Kennedy Intl. JFK. Flights from $507

    Select flight to Liberty Intl. EWR. Cheapest option available. Flights from $250

    Select flight to LaGuardia LGA. Flights from $345

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What month is the cheapest to fly to Plum Island?

    Schedule your trip for February if you're hoping to get a deal on your fare. It's the cheapest month to fly to Plum Island. Try to avoid traveling during peak periods such as public holidays or school breaks.

    Which US cities have the cheapest flights to Plum Island?

    Usually, Los Angeles, San Francisco and Boston have cheap flights to Plum Island. However, being flexible is the secret to scoring the best prices. Book during low season or midweek to keep costs as low as possible.

    Which US cities fly direct to Plum Island?

    You can fly to Plum Island without a stopover from 58 US cities. To find a nonstop journey, use the "Direct flights only" filter when organizing your flights to Plum Island on Expedia. Then, compare the options and find the best departure from any of these cities:

    • Los Angeles
    • San Francisco
    • Boston
    • Miami
    • Orlando

    How to find a cheap flight to Plum Island?

    To find cheap flights to Plum Island, book early and travel during the low season. Want a handy tip? Depart on a Thursday and you'll typically save 16% on average compared to those who jet off on a Sunday.* Set up price tracking on the Expedia app and we'll let you know the moment your fares drop.

    *Best day of the week to book, depart and ideal booking window recommendations based on average round-trip ticket prices for January through August 2023, sourced from Airline Reporting Corporation's (ARC) global airline sales database. Percentages noted are averages.

    How to get a cheap last-minute flight to Plum Island?

    While booking in advance is typically the easiest way to save money, don't panic if your Plum Island trip is last minute. It's still possible to find cheap flights to Plum Island, especially if your plans have a little wiggle room. Try changing your dates, looking at different ticket options or flying out of another airport.

    How far in advance should I book a flight to Plum Island?

    Secure your flight to Plum Island two to four months ahead if you're flying in from an international destination. For domestic travel, the usual timeframe is 28 days in advance. Bigger savings and a wider variety of departure dates, schedules and seating options are just some of the awesome benefits of booking early.*

    *Best day of the week to book, depart and ideal booking window recommendations based on average round-trip ticket prices for January through August 2023, sourced from Airline Reporting Corporation's (ARC) global airline sales database. Percentages noted are averages.

    Which day of the week is the cheapest day to buy a plane ticket to Plum Island?

    You'll save an average of 8% if you buy plane tickets on a Sunday instead of Fridays, which tend to be the most expensive day to book.* When it comes to snapping up a cheap flight to Plum Island, it's all about timing.

    *Best day of the week to book, depart and ideal booking window recommendations based on average round-trip ticket prices for January through August 2023, sourced from Airline Reporting Corporation's (ARC) global airline sales database. Percentages noted are averages.

    Which airlines fly to Plum Island?

    You can choose from a good variety of airlines that offer flights to Plum Island. A few of your options are:

    • Delta Air Lines - 12,252 flights to Plum Island each month, including 6,687 flights to LaGuardia Airport (LGA) per month.
    • United Airlines - 9,946 flights to Plum Island each month, including 9,000 flights to Liberty Intl. Airport (EWR) per month.
    • American Airlines - 5,988 flights to Plum Island each month, including 3,362 flights to LaGuardia Airport (LGA) per month.

    Where do you fly into Plum Island?

    The main hub when you fly to Plum Island is John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport (JFK), but there are other nearby options like Liberty Intl. Airport (EWR) and LaGuardia Airport (LGA). You can also touch down at Westchester County Airport (HPN) and MacArthur Airport (ISP) when flying to Plum Island.

    Can I save money by booking a Plum Island trip package?

    You could possibly save hundreds of dollars if you lock in a Plum Island flight and hotel package deal on Expedia. And you'll make life easier by having all your travel plans in one place. Try bundling flights and accommodations with extras such as activities and car rentals for your own personalized Plum Island break.

    Can I change or cancel my flight to Plum Island?

    If you bought your flight to Plum Island in the last 24 hours, you can typically change or cancel it without fees. After that, additional costs may apply depending on the airline's terms and conditions. To learn more, check out our Customer Service Portal. Keep in mind that some flights are non-refundable, so you may be issued a credit for a future flight in place of a direct refund. When searching on Expedia, check the "No cancel fee" or "Changes included" filters to find tickets with flexible change policies.

    Travel information

    Airlines servingJetBlue Airways, Delta, American Airlines, Alaska Airlines, British Airways, Lufthansa, KLM, Swiss International Air Lines, Air France, Iberia, Finnair, TAP Portugal, Turkish Airlines, LOT-Polish Airlines, Aer Lingus, ITA Airways, SAS, Virgin Atlantic, Air Europa, Brussels Airlines, Royal Air Maroc, Avianca, Singapore Airlines, Icelandair, Emirates, Sun Country Airlines, Copa, Condor, Qatar Airways, LATAM Airlines Group, Etihad Airways, Aeromexico, WestJet, Austrian Airlines, Cathay Pacific, United
    Popular airlineJetBlue Airways
    Roundtrip price$220

    Explore a world of travel with Expedia

    Trending flights to Plum Island

    Prices were available within the past 7 days and start at $48 for one-way flights and $88 for roundtrip, for the period specified. Prices and availability are subject to change.

    All deals

    One way

    Roundtrip

    Select Allegiant Air flight, departing Fri, Feb 12 from Orlando to Newburgh, returning Sat, Feb 20, priced at $88 Found 1 hour ago

    Fri, Feb 12 - Sat, Feb 20 · SFB · SWF · Roundtrip

    *Available to One Key members.