Historic Hotels in Cruz Bay from $265

"We loved being in a private setting and close to everything in town at the same time. The porch was our favorite spot. It felt a little like being in a treehouse. Having two bedrooms was wonderful for my wife and I and our thirteen year old. Not a lot of negative to report. Parking was a challenge at times, but wouldn’t be a problem at all for someone from a city where parking in tight spots is the norm. I don’t think the place had an ice cream scoop(we made do with one of the big spoons), but that was our only glitch. Would definitely stay there again and would recommend it to others."

"Friendly helpful staff, access to pool and ocean, location- easy walk to restaurants and bars! We would love to return!"

"Everything was perfect, room, view, staff etc spent 5 nights will be back in July for 6 nights"

"This property has this best view ever from the corner deck."

"Awesome thanks "

"Karen and owner were very friendly and hospitable."

"Perfect home base in Cruz Bay! Staff were great, restaurant was very good and well-priced, rooms were simple and had everything we needed. The free off-street parking is a huge bonus if you have a rental car. Can’t be happier with our weeklong stay."

"Wr had an amazing stay at the Blue Dolphin. The property was perfect for us. The patio area is amazing and provided a great spot to spend time outside. The property’s proximity to Cruz Bay was ideal. The owners and property manager were also great to deal with. "

"The villa is spacious, with plenty of indoor and outdoor areas to spend time with family or friends. The view is incredible. Loved the pool, hot tub, pool table, outdoor kitchen. The indoor kitchen was well equipped. The owners were super communicators and responsive to our questions. A great place to stay!"