Find all hotels by Red Roof Inn in Fire Island, NY from $136

"Very nice staff and room. Recommended 💯"

"In general terms it is an excellent solution for travellers. Very good conditions"

"The staff was pleasant..Breakfast was good"

"All was clean, friendly, and parking was open and available."

"The sink faucet was lose and falling off the sink. The shower dripped. There were no towels in the two adjoining rooms, and there was a large spider in one of the beds. This was the worse hotel experience I have on three continents. I spoke to staff and sent a text and was assured they would fix everything. But nothing was fixed. I had to go lobby to get towels. Poor Poor service. Not a good experience when traveling for a wedding. "

"No restaurant services for breakfast during weekdays, only Saturday and Sunday. Having breakfast available all the time is a plus."

"Room was clean, staff was amazing, plenty of parking, breakfast was ok."

"The issues began at check-in, where only one of the three elevators was operational. Upon entering my room (Room, 1 King Bed, Accessible), I found the following: Safety & Maintenance: The AC system made loud, alarming noises resembling fireworks when activated. Additionally, the television depicted only static. Cleanliness & Upkeep: The floors were filthy, mirrors were stained, and both the carpeting and furniture were heavily worn and marked. Plumbing Issues: The toilet ran constantly, the shower/bath nozzles were rusted, and the water pressure was virtually non-existent"

"We had a great stay. We got in late and there was warm water and tea. The room and breakfast area were clean. The staff were nice. We will definitely stay there again! "