A lighthouse, a red-roofed building, and a wooden structure near a coastal area.

Find all hotels by Preferred in Fire Island, NY from $260

  • Upfront pricing

    Our total price for your stay includes taxes and fees

  • Treat yourself

    Save 10% or more on over 100,000 hotels worldwide with Member Prices
    Learn about One Key

  • Be picky

    Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

Tonight
Oct 10 - Oct 11
Tomorrow
Oct 11 - Oct 12
Next weekend
Oct 16 - Oct 18
In two weeks
Oct 23 - Oct 25

Our top choices for Fire Island Preferred

A hotel room with a large bed, a desk, a chair, and a window with curtains.
An outdoor seating area with wicker furniture, a hanging flower planter, and a clock.
A garden pathway with a white pergola and hydrangea bushes.
A lobby with a reception desk, green chairs, a coffee table with a plant, and a glass railing in the background.

1. The Garden City Hotel

The Garden City Hotel
Garden City
United States
Janice K
$233 nightly
$260 total
Nov 1 - Nov 2
Total with taxes and fees
The Garden City Hotel
View all properties
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Top Fire Island Hotel Reviews

Hilton Garden Inn Westbury

Hilton Garden Inn Westbury

10/10 Excellent
"What a nice hotel and friendly staff in a very good location. Everything is reasonably close for our-of-town people looking for an efficient and cost-ftiendly alternative to areas close to Manhattan. Seriously nice, easy walk to LIRR, many restaurants are available and Jones' beach is only 30 minutes away by car. With LIRR -20 minutes to UBS, or an hour to Penn Station."
Brian 3-night trip
Posted 5 hours ago
Hilton Garden Inn Westbury
Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham

Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham

8/10 Good
"Great experience! Clean, comfortable, mostly quiet and safe. The staff were professional and there was plenty of convenient parking. The restaurant food was decent for a quick bite. I would stay here again."
Stacey 4-night trip
Posted 10 hours ago
Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
Hampton Inn Garden City Long Island

Hampton Inn Garden City Long Island

10/10 Excellent
"The room was clean, staff was friendly, didn't use any of the amenities, and was charged for parking, which I didn't know about. I parked my own car, so I was charged to park overnight, which is ridiculous with the price I paid for an overnight stay."
Catherine 1-night trip
Posted 12 hours ago
Hampton Inn Garden City Long Island
Inn at Jericho

Inn at Jericho

8/10 Good
"The property was smaller and not as modern but it was clean and doable for the price and the amount of time I needed the room for. I would stay there again! 4 stars!!!"
Deborah 2-night trip
Posted 12 hours ago
Inn at Jericho
Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

10/10 Excellent
"The room was clean, staff pleasant and breakfast a cut above the rest. I'd definitely come back!"
Cyrus 1-night trip
Posted 15 hours ago
Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island
The Garden City Hotel

The Garden City Hotel

10/10 Excellent
"The was always most helpful with meeting our needs."
Francine 1-night trip
Posted 2 days ago
The Garden City Hotel
Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook by IHG

Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook by IHG

8/10 Good
"Convenient location. Not bad.. Most staff really need to smile.. Pool was in desperate need of being cleaned. Outside of property was beautiful. Plenty if places to relax and sit outside."
Lisa 4-night trip
Posted 2 days ago
Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook by IHG

Explore a world of travel with Expedia