Find all hotels by Preferred in Fire Island, NY from $305

"Parking was very easy, property is clean, friendly staff. However, lack some basic things."

"Deposit was charged onto my account at the check in. Not HOLD!!! It was actually charged to my account and it will take 7-10 days to return to my card. I never seen any place that does the same way. And when asked , the counter girl had a major attitude problem. Not recommended for anyone to stay here………. CAUTION !⚠️ CAUTION ! ⚠️ CAUTION ! ⚠️ CAUTION !⚠️ CAUTION ! ⚠️ CAUTION ! ⚠️ CAUTION !⚠️ CAUTION ! ⚠️ CAUTION ! ⚠️ CAUTION !⚠️ CAUTION ! ⚠️ CAUTION ! ⚠️ CAUTION !⚠️ CAUTION ! ⚠️ CAUTION ! ⚠️"

"Rooms are spacious and very clean .The bathroom is larger than most hotels. Easy parking. Plenty to do and eat in the area..Would definitely stay here again and highly recommend."

"Maintanence"

"Yes "

"There was no breakfast, to my knowledge."

"Tv in first room didn't work. Moved to 2nd floor. Hallway smelled terrible. Room was comfortable and clean. Bed adequate "

"The breakfast menu is continental and perfect! I could come up in my bathrobe and slippers and grab some fresh fruit. Make a waffle and go back to my room, Clif The chef helped me even make the waffle! He’s amazing and such an asset! And I love the spa, mainly I used the gym and loved the variety of equipment and they even supply water and fresh towels! I always stay here because all the amenities are there for you and they go to the extra mile! "

"Excellent Hotel stayed multiple times for friendly staff. Excellent breakfast."