Search Mcguffey Cottages

"My brother and I take a weekend every year to go fishing together. Indian Lake was a good choice and the house was spot on the description. Connecting with Cyndi (host) was easy to answer any questions and the smell of the fresh brownies as we walked in was a very nice welcome! Though the water had an unpleasant smell, just running it a bit helped it to go away. Private covered boat dock with a lift? Wow. Nice rental. Friendly neighbors. Great fishing!"

"We loved this cozy cottage and the location! Indian lake is beautiful. We will definitely be back to visit in the summer!"

"Owners are easy to work with and helped make our stay perfect. Highly recommend staying here."

"Very comfortable and a lot of amenities. Short walk to the lake!"

"The house had a great location that met all our needs. Great views of the sunrise! Being near the RV park gave us a front row seat for the fireworks show Sunday night! Overall, a great experience!"

"It was good. The pictures for the house made it look larger than it was but still was nice."

"The house was very nice and laid out well for our needs. The location was great. We felt that the house had not been checked for cleanliness and that everything was in working order prior to our arrival. Had issue with the toilet not working upon our arrival. The host did arrive the next day and repaired it."

"This is my go to stay when visiting Indian Lake. Located right behind Froggys, this place couldnt be anymore convenient."

"Very clean, very accessable to lake"

"Home was as advertised. Cute decor! Hosts were attentive and easy to communicate with. Very close to restaurants and the lake."

"Our host was awesome! She was more than welcoming to us and our dog. I can’t believe she had food bowls, waste bags, and towels for our beagle. The bedding was outstanding. Wonderful body wash in the shower and hand soaps at the sinks. The kitchenette had everything we needed. Location was great as well. Easy walk to restaurants or an easy drive to things on the other side of the lake. Convenient to Ohio Caverns and other points of interest."

"Very nice for a weekend cabin!"

"Had a wonderful time at the Nook to watch the total solar eclipse! The place was exactly what was expected from the listing. And John was a great host - very nice, responsive, and even set out some extra eclipse glasses for us to use on our visit - so thoughtful! All in all, great stay!"

"The cottage at Indian Lake was just as described. It is minutes to the lake and walking distance to several restaurants. The cottage was clean and the area is very quiet. Great place for a couples getaway. The fenced in backyard was perfect for our dog. I highly recommend staying here."

"Nice little weekend get away on the lake. Great little cottage along with very nice neighbors."

"Owners are easy to work with and helped make our stay perfect. Highly recommend staying here."

"My brother and I take a weekend every year to go fishing together. Indian Lake was a good choice and the house was spot on the description. Connecting with Cyndi (host) was easy to answer any questions and the smell of the fresh brownies as we walked in was a very nice welcome! Though the water had an unpleasant smell, just running it a bit helped it to go away. Private covered boat dock with a lift? Wow. Nice rental. Friendly neighbors. Great fishing!"

"Very nice little cottage, walking distance to water, nice neighborhood tavern "LuLu's on the Lake" Making a good recovery from recent tornado-neighbors helping neighbors! I would stay here again!"