Where to stay

in Bay Shore

No matter what kind of place you're searching for, we'd like to help you find a spot that's a great fit for your trip. Atlantique is a top neighborhood to call home while you're in town.

Travelers to Bay Shore like its beaches. Nature lovers might enjoy a trip to Robert Moses Beach and Sunken Forest while exploring the area. Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal and Fire Island Lighthouse are also a few notable stops. Whether you're looking to stay right in the heart of town or you're interested in a more secluded spot, we'd like to help you find a great place to stay in Bay Shore.

Top-rated places to stay near the beach in Bay Shore

Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island is a 2.5-star hotel great for a beach getaway. It offers a seasonal outdoor pool and private balconies. You'll be well placed to visit top beaches like Ocean Beach and Ho-Hum Beach located close by.

Recommended hotels

Top places to stay in Bay Shore with breakfast

The Ocean Bay House is a B&B with free breakfast and free WiFi.

Recommended hotels

Top romantic accommodations in Bay Shore

Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island is a property featuring rainfall showerheads and free WiFi that guests like for its prime location.

Recommended hotels

Top rated places to stay in Bay Shore for families

The Fire Island Beach House is a hotel featuring an outdoor pool and a restaurant. The Ocean Bay House is a B&B featuring free parking and free breakfast.

Recommended hotels

Top places to stay with pools in Bay Shore

The Fire Island Beach House is a hotel featuring a seasonal outdoor pool and conference space. It's located a short 4-minute walk from Beach.

Recommended hotels

Top places to stay for budget travelers in Bay Shore

Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island is a 2-star property that's ideal for frugal travelers, featuring free WiFi and free parking and noted for its prime location. It's just a short 1-minute walk from Gilgo State Park. Bay Shore Inn is a 2-star hotel featuring free WiFi. The Fire Island Beach House is a 2.5-star hotel that's ideal for frugal travelers, featuring free WiFi and air conditioning and noted for its helpful staff.

Recommended hotels