Villas in Oyster Bay

"This is a great place to stay in a gated community, close to the beach. Shanna, the owner, quickly responded to any questions I had. There’s even a shuttle that can pick you up at your property for the beach! HIGHLY recommend."

"Amazing place to stay, highly recommend!"

"Great property and location. The Wharf was super close and the Daquiri Bar was a great time. Host was very friendly and informative. Comfortable stay and would definitely stay again. "

"The condo was roomy, well equipped and very private with a short walk from the beach and pool. Would definitely return!"

"Great location, clean, loved the pool. Just bring your own toilet paper, paper towels and trash bags if you are staying awhile. Only one roll per bathroom, no extra garbage bags. "

"I won't repeat what's already been written by others (the distance from the beach, the kid bedroom location, etc). I will add that there is mildew/mold in the downstairs AC unit. Vacasa did say they would clean it, but I asked them not to while we were there. If you are allergic to mold/mildew, you may want to check that it has been cleaned properly before booking."

"We had a wonderful vacation! The house was beautiful and the amenities at Lost Key are great. Check-in and out was effortless and we will be back."

"This property was beautiful and very clean. The neighborhood was quiet & peaceful. We were a family of 9 that stayed together, 4 adults and 5 teenagers. The place was very spacious. The decor was beautiful and everything we needed was there. The kids spent a lot of time on the pickleball courts. If you don't mind walking the pool and courts aren't too far. Parking at the pool & pickleball courts are very limited and can get crowded pretty quick. Also, the parking across the street at the beach...