Find hotels near Finger Lake, New Carlisle from $67

"Clean, comfortable, friendly."

"Really beautiful hotel and room. "

"welcoming staff - breakfast was out and ready at 6:30 as promised. no complaints for a quick overnight, would stay again"

"Great place to stay"

"Clean room, friendly staff, delicious breakfast. "

"it was perfect!!"

"We stayed here twice. The first was on our way to the Michigan thumb. The second was 10 days later on our return home due to mother nature. Snow/ice. The hotel is clean and they have a treadmill, which is a necesity for me. The breakfast was decent too. So if you are looking for a clean and reasonably priced hotel this is a great option. "

"Yes"

"We had a wonderful stay at the Brewery Lodge and Supper Club. Our room was incredibly cozy and comfortable—warm, inviting, and the perfect place to unwind. Dinner was truly exceptional; the food was chef-quality in every way, beautifully prepared and full of flavor. Our server, Dan, was excellent—attentive, personable, and made the whole meal feel even more special. Every part of our experience felt thoughtful and elevated. Highly recommend this gem for anyone looking for a relaxing stay paired with outstanding dining. We’ll absolutely be back."