Find Historic Hotels in Fishers Island, NY
Upfront pricingOur total price for your stay includes taxes and fees
Treat yourselfSave 10% or more on over 100,000 hotels worldwide with Member Prices
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check availability on Fishers Island Historic Hotels
Our top choices for Fishers Island historic hotels
9.6 out of 10, Exceptional, (1001)
"The Taber Inne is the ONLY place I stay when visiting Mystic. Great staff, rooms are comfortable, beautiful pool and walking distance to downtown. "
Kathryn
$161 nightly
The price is $185
Jan 1 - Jan 2, 2026
Total with taxes and fees
8.4 out of 10, Very Good, (1003)
"The young lady at the front desk that welcomed us was absolutely the best."
Corey
$77 nightly
The price is $89
Dec 21 - Dec 22
Total with taxes and fees
Lakeside cottage ON the water with beautiful views up the lake!
Lakeside cottage ON the water with beautiful views up the lake!Ledyard
9.8 out of 10, Exceptional, (191)
"There were stunning views, it was very relaxing, and we had excellent communication with the host. We couldn’t be happier, it was perfect! Kayaking was the best part. Plenty to see and do in the area as well."
Heather S.
$208 nightly
The price is $236
Dec 17 - Dec 18
Total with taxes and fees
9.0 out of 10, Wonderful, (202)
"Great weekend trip "
Timothy
$232 nightly
The price is $265
Dec 28 - Dec 29
Total with taxes and fees
Charming 1845 Home in the Heart of Mystic – Walk to Everything!
Charming 1845 Home in the Heart of Mystic – Walk to Everything!Mystic
9.8 out of 10, Exceptional, (158)
"Nice spot - about as close as you can get to the restaurants and shops downtown, but still quiet. "
Bryan M.
$214 nightly
The price is $243
Dec 15 - Dec 16
Total with taxes and fees
Unique Retreat w/ Private Patio, 4 King Beds & BBQ
Unique Retreat w/ Private Patio, 4 King Beds & BBQGroton
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (126)
"We had an amazing stay at Merritt farm! The host was super accommodating and the house was perfect for our family. Hope has made sure the house has all the comforts of home and is decorated beautifully! The location is a great home base to explore this beautiful area. We would highly recommend staying here and we hope to return. "
Robin G.
$397 nightly
The price is $449
Dec 16 - Dec 17
Total with taxes and fees
Lakeside cottage overhanging the water, beautiful window views across the lake
Lakeside cottage overhanging the water, beautiful window views across the lakeLedyard
9.8 out of 10, Exceptional, (217)
"Very comfortable, easy to get to and had everything you could need in a house rental! "
Anna K.
$258 nightly
The price is $292
Jan 4 - Jan 5, 2026
Total with taxes and fees
8.8 out of 10, Excellent, (1001)
"Great place!"
Jill
$236 nightly
The price is $271
Dec 15 - Dec 16
Total with taxes and fees
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Top Fishers Island Hotel Reviews
Spark by Hilton Mystic Groton
10/10 Excellent
Frequently asked questions
Explore a world of travel with Expedia
- Flights from Elizabeth Field
- Flights from New York (JFK) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Chicago (ORD) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from White Plains (HPN) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from East Hampton (HTO) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Boston (BOS) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Baltimore (BWI) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Nantucket (ACK) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Montauk (MTP) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from San Francisco (SFO) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Minneapolis (MSP) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Hopscotch Air East Hampton (HTO) to Fishers Island (FID) flights
- Flights from Cincinnati (CVG) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Orlando (MCO) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Los Angeles (LAX) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Louisville (SDF) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Miami (MIA) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Washington (DCA) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Wilkes-Barre (AVP) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Hopscotch Air New London (GON) to Fishers Island (FID) flights
- Flights from Cleveland (CLE) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from San Diego (SAN) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from West Palm Beach (PBI) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Newburgh (SWF) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Appleton (ATW) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Panama City (ECP) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights to Elizabeth Field
- Flights from Dallas (DFW) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Hopscotch Air Westhampton (FOK) to Fishers Island (FID) flights
- Flights from Indianapolis (IND) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Denver (DEN) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Albany (ALB) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Charlotte (CLT) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Fort Myers (RSW) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Atlanta (ATL) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Hartford (BDL) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Portsmouth (PSM) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from New York (NYC) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from New York (LGA) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from New York (JFK) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Montauk
- Flights from Boston (BOS) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from New York (LGA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from White Plains (HPN) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Washington (DCA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Philadelphia (PHL) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Providence (PVD) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Islip (ISP) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Teterboro (TEB) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Block Island (BID) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Chicago (ORD) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Atlantic City (ACY) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Hyannis (HYA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Hartford (BDL) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Westerly (WST) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Los Angeles (LAX) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Nantucket (ACK) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from New York (NYC) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from New Haven (HVN) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Albany (ALB) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Baltimore (BWI) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Fort Lauderdale (FLL) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Charlotte (CLT) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Miami (MIA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Pittsburgh (PIT) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Dallas (DFW) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from New York (NYS) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Buffalo (BUF) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Atlanta (ATL) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Syracuse (SYR) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Detroit (DTW) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Austin (AUS) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from San Francisco (SFO) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Danbury (DXR) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Raleigh (RDU) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Nashville (BNA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Vineyard Haven (MVY) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Kansas City (MCI) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Tampa (TPA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Newport (NPT) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Trenton (TTN) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from West Palm Beach (PBI) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Bangkok (BKK) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Orlando (MCO) to Montauk (MTP)