Fishers Island Vacations from $577

The location was perfect for the purpose of our trip as it was only a short walk to the Morgan Library and other attractions we were visiting. The staff was friendly and helpful. The room was basic but clean and the air conditioning worked well. The hotel is older and while it shows some wear & tear it’s not being neglected. We arrived on an early flight and the front desk let us drop our luggage off so we could hit the sites prior to checking in. There aren’t many “amenities” hence the low score for that category but the hotel served our needs for this trip and I wouldn’t mind staying there again.

Such a beautiful and magical experience at this hotel . I loved every minute of my stay !

The hotel is very well situated, and we got great service (shoutout to Manuel at reception!). The public areas and the room were all very clean and well maintained. The room doors slam very loudly, and so when other guests leave or arrive early morning or late at night we hear doors slamming. It would be accommodating if complimentary water bottles were replenished daily and not just upon arrival. We would stay there again!

Everything was excellent as well as location to Times square. High floor and great view. Clean and comfy. Breakfast excellent.

The hotel is in a great location but was disappointed in my room. The closet was more like a cupboard and I had to get creative on hanging my clothes. There is no chest for drawers. The lighting switches are confusing but figured them out. Even on the full lighting, the room is dim. The staff was great.