$51 Car Rental Fishers Island, NY
Search and Compare from Car Companies in Fishers Island
Featured car rental suppliers
Compare from agencies
Change your mind: penalty-free cancellation on many/select car rentals
Treat yourself: One Key members save 10% or more on over 1 million car rentals
Shop Smart: Compare car suppliers and package your flight, hotel, and car to save
Top Car Deals in Fishers Island
* Price found within the past 6 days. Click for updated prices.
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Special
Managers Special or similar
New York, New York, USA
$51
includes taxes & fees
$34 per day
found 12 hours ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Economy
Kia Rio or similar
Groton, Connecticut, USA
$69
includes taxes & fees
$53 per day
found 1 day ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Standard Elite Special
Ford Mustang Mach-E or similar
GROTON, USA
$70
includes taxes & fees
$54 per day
found 1 day ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Compact
Kia Soul or similar
Groton, Connecticut, USA
$71
includes taxes & fees
$55 per day
found 1 day ago
Thu, Aug 28 to Fri, Aug 29
Midsize SUV
Chevrolet Bolt EUV or similar
Groton, Connecticut, USA
$57
includes taxes & fees
$57 per day
found 22 hours ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Fullsize
Toyota Camry or similar
Groton, Connecticut, USA
$75
includes taxes & fees
$58 per day
found 1 day ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Standard
Volkswagen Jetta or similar
GROTON, USA
$76
includes taxes & fees
$59 per day
found 1 day ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Midsize Elite
Tesla Short Range Model 3 or similar
Jamaica, New York, USA
$84
includes taxes & fees
$60 per day
found 12 hours ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Fullsize Elite Pickup Regular Cab
Ram 2500 Big Horn or similar
Groton, Connecticut, USA
$84
includes taxes & fees
$75 per day
found 1 day ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Premium
Nissan Maxima or similar
Old Saybrook, Connecticut, USA
$87
includes taxes & fees
$76 per day
found 1 day ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Luxury
Audi A4 or BMW 3 Series or similar
OLD SAYBROOK, USA
$96
includes taxes & fees
$84 per day
found 1 day ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Premium Elite SUV
Audi Q5 or similar
New York City, New York, USA
$119
includes taxes & fees
$84 per day
found 10 hours ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Mini Van
Chrysler Pacifica or similar
New York City, New York, USA
$130
includes taxes & fees
$91 per day
found 10 hours ago
Tue, Aug 26 to Wed, Aug 27
Luxury Elite
Genesis G80E or similar
Jamaica, New York, USA
$153
includes taxes & fees
$111 per day
found 12 hours ago
Lowest prices found within the past 12 hours. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Frequently asked questions
Car Rental Information
| SUV, Full Size, Economy | |
| $51 | |
| $57 | |
| $69 | |
| Airport Transportation | |
| Airport Car Rentals |
Finding the cheapest car rentals in Fishers Island
Using our Search Wizard
If the deals that are available on our page do not suit your needs, then enter Fishers Island into the search wizard at the top of the page. We will compare all the best deals available for your car rental in Fishers Island and provide you with a list of the cheapest options, with no added fees.
Renting a car in Fishers Island
Pay at pickup is available, so you don’t have to worry about spending your money until you arrive at your vehicle in Fishers Island. We partner with reliable partners that guarantee an enjoyable experience for solo travelers, couples, and families. Package your car with a flight or hotel to unlock even more savings from Expedia.
Expected prices in Fishers Island
Prices are subject to seasonal change depending on when you decide to arrange your car rental but right now you can book from $51.
Flexibility & Cancellation
Most car suppliers offer penalty-free cancellations, so you don’t have to worry about losing money if your plans change. To cancel your booking log into your account through the Trips portal. Click manage booking and cancel this car. If you needed to alter your booking, then you can create a new one once you have canceled.
We all love being rewarded
One Key members save 10% or more on select hotels, cars, activities and vacation rentals. Not only that, earn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible hotels, vacation rentals, flights, car rentals, and more when you book across our family of brands: Expedia, Hotels.com and VRBO. Learn more and join today.
Car classes available from Expedia in 2025
The classes of vehicles available will change depending on your chosen location.
Explore a world of travel with Expedia
Explore a world of travel with Expedia
- Flights from Elizabeth Field
- Flights from New York (JFK) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Chicago (ORD) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from White Plains (HPN) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from East Hampton (HTO) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Boston (BOS) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Baltimore (BWI) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Nantucket (ACK) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Montauk (MTP) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from San Francisco (SFO) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Minneapolis (MSP) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Hopscotch Air East Hampton (HTO) to Fishers Island (FID) flights
- Flights from Cincinnati (CVG) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Orlando (MCO) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Los Angeles (LAX) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Louisville (SDF) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Miami (MIA) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Washington (DCA) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Cleveland (CLE) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from San Diego (SAN) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Wilkes-Barre (AVP) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Hopscotch Air New London (GON) to Fishers Island (FID) flights
- Flights from Panama City (ECP) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Albany (ALB) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Hopscotch Air Westhampton (FOK) to Fishers Island (FID) flights
- Flights from West Palm Beach (PBI) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Appleton (ATW) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Fort Myers (RSW) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Newburgh (SWF) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Dallas (DFW) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights to Elizabeth Field
- Flights from Indianapolis (IND) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Charlotte (CLT) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Denver (DEN) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Atlanta (ATL) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Hartford (BDL) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from Portsmouth (PSM) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from New York (NYC) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from New York (LGA) to Fishers Island (FID)
- Flights from New York (JFK) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Montauk
- Flights from Boston (BOS) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from New York (LGA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from White Plains (HPN) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Washington (DCA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Philadelphia (PHL) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Providence (PVD) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Islip (ISP) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Teterboro (TEB) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Block Island (BID) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Chicago (ORD) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Atlantic City (ACY) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Hyannis (HYA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Hartford (BDL) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Westerly (WST) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Los Angeles (LAX) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Nantucket (ACK) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from New York (NYC) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from New Haven (HVN) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Albany (ALB) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Baltimore (BWI) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Fort Lauderdale (FLL) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Charlotte (CLT) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Miami (MIA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Pittsburgh (PIT) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Dallas (DFW) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from New York (NYS) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Buffalo (BUF) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Atlanta (ATL) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Syracuse (SYR) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Detroit (DTW) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Austin (AUS) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from San Francisco (SFO) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Danbury (DXR) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Raleigh (RDU) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Nashville (BNA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Vineyard Haven (MVY) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Kansas City (MCI) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Tampa (TPA) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Newport (NPT) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Trenton (TTN) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from West Palm Beach (PBI) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Bangkok (BKK) to Montauk (MTP)
- Flights from Orlando (MCO) to Montauk (MTP)