Find 2 Star Hotels in Sheldrake, NY from $91

"Hotel was clean and staff was pleasant!"

"VERY CLEAN, VERY COMFORTABLE BED, GOOD BREAKFAST, LOVELY STAFF!"

"Property was very clean and well maintained. Close to wineries and Watkins Glen. We enjoyed our stay. "

"Very clean"

"Nothing likeable here- Expedia bluffed"

"Absolutely loved this stay. So clean and cozy and had great organic products to use. It had amazing energy!!"

"We really enjoyed our stay. Loved the location."

"Everything was easy from checking in to enjoying this beautiful home...Dennis' place is top notch and he has thought of everything to make your stay comfortable. "

"Diana was such a pleasant and gracious host. She gave recommendations of places to make sure to visit and they did not disappoint! The room was clean and had a beautiful atmosphere. I would highly recommend staying here and looking forward to my next visit. "

"We stayed in the upper unit, right on the lake, great views, nice big decks all around the property, clean and well maintained, nicely furnished, owner was lovely and very responsive, will definitely stay again "

"The house is extremely spacious and the view was everything we wanted. Home was stocked with everything you could need. If you stay here and go for a drive stop at Dave & Rita’s Farm Market the homemade breads were absolutely delicious!! Great stay - would highly recommend!"

"We had a great stay! The cabin was super cute, cozy, and well-stocked with everything we needed for a comfortable visit. It had a charming vibe and made for a relaxing getaway. The only downside was that the water cooler needed a good cleaning, and the road leading to the cabin was long and a bit rough. But overall, it was a lovely spot and we really enjoyed our time there!"