$57 Car Rental Shelter Island, NY

Reasons to book a car rental in and around Shelter Island

Renting a car in Shelter Island is a great choice for those looking to explore the area's attractions with freedom and flexibility. With a rental car, you can easily visit key spots such as Gardiner's Bay Country Club for a round of golf, Shell Beach for a relaxing day by the shore, or Mashomack Preserve for outdoor activities with family and friends. The convenience of having a vehicle allows you to manage luggage easily while accommodating any travel plans you may have.

Additionally, a rental car makes it simple to discover nearby popular destinations. The charming city of Greenport is only 3 miles away, featuring 67 Steps Beach and the East End Seaport Maritime Museum. Just 5 miles from Shelter Island, Sag Harbor offers attractions like Havens Beach and Sag Harbor Marine Park. For those wishing to experience the Hamptons, it's a short 9-mile drive to enjoy the picturesque beaches and local culture. Whether you're seeking outdoor adventures, romantic getaways, or beach-related experiences, having a car rental in Shelter Island enhances your travel experience significantly.

Where to stay around Shelter Island

• Greenport: Located 3 miles from Shelter Island, Greenport offers a charming seaside experience. Visitors can enjoy outdoor activities, romantic beach moments, and explore local attractions such as the beautiful 67 Steps Beach and Orient Point County Park, perfect for family outings. Greenport is also known for its vibrant food scene, featuring nearby wineries and vineyards, making it an ideal spot for those looking to indulge in local flavors while enjoying the scenic views.
• Hamptons: Situated 9 miles away from Shelter Island, the Hamptons are renowned for their stunning beaches and outdoor activities. This area is perfect for a romantic getaway, with highlights including the beautiful Cooper's Beach and East Hampton Main Beach. The Hamptons also offer a rich selection of local wineries and vineyards, making it a great destination for beach lovers and food enthusiasts alike. The best time to visit is during the summer season when the beaches are at their finest.
• Sag Harbor: Just 5 miles from Shelter Island, Sag Harbor is a picturesque city that attracts travelers with its outdoor adventures and beach vibes. Key points of interest include Sag Harbor Marine Park, ideal for those seeking adventure, and Havens Beach, which is perfect for a relaxing day by the water. With its charming atmosphere and access to nearby wineries, Sag Harbor is a wonderful choice for a romantic retreat or a family vacation.

10 tips to save on your car rental in and around Shelter Island

1. Use filters to find the right car: Refine your search by selecting vehicle types and specific features. Whether you need an SUV for added space, a convertible for summer drives, or an economy car for budget-friendly travel, utilize the filters on Expedia to discover the ideal option for your trip.
2. Book in advance to help lower costs: Rental prices can vary based on demand, so it's wise to secure your car well ahead of your trip. By booking early, you're likely to lock in lower rates and enjoy better availability, particularly during peak seasons.
3. Consider a smaller car for savings: Smaller vehicles typically have lower rental costs and are easier to maneuver and park in crowded areas. Mid-size cars strike a good balance between affordability, comfort, and fuel efficiency.
4. Age guidelines: Drivers under 30 may encounter higher deposits or daily fees, and certain types of vehicles—such as SUVs or premium models—might not be available. This can also apply to renters over 70 years old. Always verify the age requirements before making a reservation.
5. Check fuel policies: Some rental companies require a full-to-full fuel policy, which means you must return the car with a full tank to avoid additional charges. This is typically the most advantageous option. Others may offer full-to-empty or prepaid fueling options, which are also acceptable. Just ensure you return the car empty in that case.
6. Save on city and airport pickups: Picking up your rental car at airports often incurs a surcharge, but the convenience might justify the extra cost.
7. Know your payment options: Many car rental companies only accept credit cards for payment.
8. Understand your insurance coverage: Car rental insurance can help you avoid unexpected expenses and provides peace of mind in case something unforeseen occurs during your trip. Adding car rental insurance is straightforward when booking with Expedia.
9. Consider unlimited mileage: If you plan on taking long road trips, look for rental options that offer unlimited mileage to prevent additional charges.
10. Bring your driver's license and ID: A valid driver's license is necessary to rent a car.

Finding the cheapest car rentals in Shelter Island

Using our Search Wizard

If the deals that are available on our page do not suit your needs, then enter Shelter Island into the search wizard at the top of the page. We will compare all the best deals available for your car rental in Shelter Island and provide you with a list of the cheapest options, with no added fees.

Renting a car in Shelter Island

Pay at pickup is available, so you don’t have to worry about spending your money until you arrive at your vehicle in Shelter Island. We partner with reliable partners that guarantee an enjoyable experience for solo travelers, couples, and families. Package your car with a flight or hotel to unlock even more savings from Expedia.

Expected prices in Shelter Island

Prices are subject to seasonal change depending on when you decide to arrange your car rental but right now you can book from $57.

Flexibility & Cancellation

Most car suppliers offer penalty-free cancellations, so you don’t have to worry about losing money if your plans change. To cancel your booking log into your account through the Trips portal. Click manage booking and cancel this car. If you needed to alter your booking, then you can create a new one once you have canceled.

We all love being rewarded

One Key members save 10% or more on select hotels, cars, activities and vacation rentals. Not only that, earn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible hotels, vacation rentals, flights, car rentals, and more when you book across our family of brands: Expedia, Hotels.com and VRBO. Learn more and join today.

Car classes available from Expedia in 2026

The classes of vehicles available will change depending on your chosen location.

• Compact car rentals    
• Convertible car rentals    
• Economy car rentals    
• Fullsize car rentals    
• Luxury car rentals
• Midsize car rentals    
• Mini car rentals    
• Minivan rentals    
• Pickup car rentals    
• Premium car rentals
• Sportscar rentals    
• Standard car rentals    
• SUV rentals    
• Van rentals