Find all hotels by The Peninsula Group in City Island, NY from $1,432

"Easy check in and the staff was very nice "

"Great location! "

"They treat us very good. We are likely to go back."

"Rooms were perfect love the bathtub!!! Food options EVERYWHERE! Close walk to shows we were there to see! B Busy area but loved it!!"

"This is my second time staying here and I absolutely love it, it’s very convenient for my visits to NY "

"It was a very nice experience. My first time in New York and I enjoy a very good location and the room was spacious and clean. The staff super amazing!!!!"

"Quick walk from Penn station and very clean and safe"

"Clean room, helpful staff. Convenient to coffee shops and main streets for walking tours. Outside a couple of buildings down was a bit sketchy, but bearable. Bar was well stocked and staffed. Restaurant had pretty slow service so consider that if you're on a schedule. Food was reasonably good."

"Perfect location….nice staff and room "