Find vacation rentals that suit your style
Our top choices for Fire Island cottages




1. Steps to the beach | Seabreeze Cottage #3
Steps to the beach | Seabreeze Cottage #3Hampton Bays
6.0 out of 10, (3 reviews)
6.0/10
(3 reviews)
"The property needs a major cleaning and repairs. The floors were sticky, and the carpet was dirty. Furniture was dirty and soiled. There was dried food on the utensils.
The pipes groaned at all hours, several times an hour. The bed creaked with every movement. Bedroom blinds were broken and wouldn’t close all the way. The bedside lamp on the wall was falling off.
The last straw was the huge spider that jumped down from the closet onto me.
We ended up leaving after less than 24 hours and...
"The property needs a major cleaning and repairs. The floors were sticky, and the carpet was dirty. Furniture was dirty and soiled. There was dried food on the utensils.
The pipes groaned at all hours, several times an hour. The bed creaked with every movement. Bedroom blinds were broken and wouldn’t close all the way. The bedside lamp on the wall was falling off.
The last straw was the huge spider that jumped down from the closet onto me.
We ended up leaving after less than 24 hours and...Lydia
$429 nightly
The price is $454
$454 total
Nov 22 - Nov 23
Total with taxes and fees




2. Hamptons Oceanfront Oasis - Cozy 1-bedroom cottage
Hamptons Oceanfront Oasis - Cozy 1-bedroom cottageHampton Bays
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (1 review)
10/10
Exceptional
(1 review)
$354 nightly
The price is $405
$405 total
Nov 24 - Nov 25
Total with taxes and fees




3. Walk to Beach | Seabreeze Cottage #4
Walk to Beach | Seabreeze Cottage #4Hampton Bays
8.8 out of 10, Excellent, (9 reviews)
8.8/10
Excellent
(9 reviews)
"Great stay. Would stay again. "
"Great stay. Would stay again. "Weston B.
$429 nightly
The price is $454
$454 total
Nov 22 - Nov 23
Total with taxes and fees
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Learn more about Fire Island
Pristine beaches and car-free boardwalks await on this barrier island, where you can bike between quaint villages and Fire Island Lighthouse. Catch a water taxi to explore secluded spots, or join locals for sunset cocktails at bayside restaurants in Ocean Beach.

Photo by Evgeniy Kolesnikov
Open Photo by Evgeniy Kolesnikov
Top reviews in Fire Island




The Ocean Bay House
The Ocean Bay HouseBay Shore
10/10 Excellent
Wonderful inn with gracious hosts in this quiet B/B
Wonderful inn with gracious hosts in this quiet B/B
Ronald A




Come As You Are Inn
Come As You Are InnSayville
10/10 Excellent
Our first and hopefully not our last stay at the Come As You Are Inn was a wonderful experience. Mark and Ari provide a welcoming and accomodating space within which one feels at home . The accomodations are delightful . The breakfasts , including freshly baked goodies are just right to start the day. Topping it all off , we enjoyed the opportunity to engage in extended conversations with Mark and Ari exploring a myriad of topics. A rarity in todays world. If you are looking for something more...
Our first and hopefully not our last stay at the Come As You Are Inn was a wonderful experience. Mark and Ari provide a welcoming and accomodating space within which one feels at home . The accomodations are delightful . The breakfasts , including freshly baked goodies are just right to start the day. Topping it all off , we enjoyed the opportunity to engage in extended conversations with Mark and Ari exploring a myriad of topics. A rarity in todays world. If you are looking for something more...
Laura




Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse ComplexCentral Islip
10/10 Excellent
First time we had stayed at this facility. Front desk staff was outstanding and took action to make us feel very welcome. Maid service could have been better since they only came in 2 of the four days that we were guests. Had to ask the front desk for a replacement for the tissue box.
Front desk folks (Irene Reyes especially) went out of their way to make us feel welcome and secure a wheelchair for my wife during the entire stay.
Thought the pricing was a little steep but it was...
First time we had stayed at this facility. Front desk staff was outstanding and took action to make us feel very welcome. Maid service could have been better since they only came in 2 of the four days that we were guests. Had to ask the front desk for a replacement for the tissue box.
Front desk folks (Irene Reyes especially) went out of their way to make us feel welcome and secure a wheelchair for my wife during the entire stay.
Thought the pricing was a little steep but it was...
Anonymous traveler




The Bentley Hotel Southampton
The Bentley Hotel SouthamptonSouthampton
10/10 Excellent
This is a super elevated motel vibe. Area is janky but accommodations were excellent.
This is a super elevated motel vibe. Area is janky but accommodations were excellent.
Jennifer




The Preston House & Hotel
The Preston House & HotelRiverhead
10/10 Excellent
Amazing staff and excellent rooms and facilities
Amazing staff and excellent rooms and facilities
Leivona




Danfords Hotel and Marina
Danfords Hotel and MarinaPort Jefferson
10/10 Excellent
We stayed at the Dansford because we were attending a bridal shower there. A unique hotel with a marina and a ferry coming next door, a lovely view. The staff was very friendly a helpful.
The Dansford has a lot of character. It is old but not at all rundown. Our room was on the third floor with no elevator so you might want to ask for a first floor room if that will be a problem.
We stayed at the Dansford because we were attending a bridal shower there. A unique hotel with a marina and a ferry coming next door, a lovely view. The staff was very friendly a helpful.
The Dansford has a lot of character. It is old but not at all rundown. Our room was on the third floor with no elevator so you might want to ask for a first floor room if that will be a problem.
Linda




The Hampton Maid
The Hampton MaidHampton Bays
10/10 Excellent
Such a beautiful property, lots of trees, lovely landscaping. They keep Crassula in pots on all of the porches as long as weather permits. The room I stayed in (double queen) was very spacious. Wood beamed ceiling with a ceiling fan, walk in shower. Loved the restaurant that was open for breakfast daily. Open for dinner Tuesday - Saturday while I was there. It's still family owned and run after 69 years. Great dining options all around, and lots to see and do on the island - although you...
Such a beautiful property, lots of trees, lovely landscaping. They keep Crassula in pots on all of the porches as long as weather permits. The room I stayed in (double queen) was very spacious. Wood beamed ceiling with a ceiling fan, walk in shower. Loved the restaurant that was open for breakfast daily. Open for dinner Tuesday - Saturday while I was there. It's still family owned and run after 69 years. Great dining options all around, and lots to see and do on the island - although you...
ALIX




Residence Inn by Marriott Melville
Residence Inn by Marriott MelvilleMelville
10/10 Excellent
Immaculately clean and the most helpful staff. All of the staff that we interacted with during our 7 day stay were approachable, and friendly. And went out of their way to be helpful. It was refreshing to to see employees who genuinely cared about their guests comfort. All compliments were received with pride and appreciation.
Well done!
Immaculately clean and the most helpful staff. All of the staff that we interacted with during our 7 day stay were approachable, and friendly. And went out of their way to be helpful. It was refreshing to to see employees who genuinely cared about their guests comfort. All compliments were received with pride and appreciation.
Well done!
Bernadette




Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate
Oheka Castle Hotel & EstateHuntington
10/10 Excellent
The hotel is amazing, the staff were very welcoming. I would recommend this hotel to anyone. Great experience.
The hotel is amazing, the staff were very welcoming. I would recommend this hotel to anyone. Great experience.
M




The Quogue Club at Hallock House
The Quogue Club at Hallock HouseQuogue
10/10 Excellent
Felt like home
Felt like home
Lynn




Canoe Place Inn and Cottages
Canoe Place Inn and CottagesHampton Bays
10/10 Excellent
Gorgeous gorgeous hotel!! And the absolute nicest staff I have ever encountered! The restaurant breakfast wasn’t that great but everything else was 11/10!!
Gorgeous gorgeous hotel!! And the absolute nicest staff I have ever encountered! The restaurant breakfast wasn’t that great but everything else was 11/10!!
Quinne




Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven
Hampton Inn Long Island-BrookhavenFarmingville
10/10 Excellent
nice pool I ujswed it good hot water clean I also went to the fitnesscenter and tried a feew ofthe machines all good bed excellent bathroom sink too high I like a shower not a tub shower but only a shower to stand in. get rid of the tub.
nice pool I ujswed it good hot water clean I also went to the fitnesscenter and tried a feew ofthe machines all good bed excellent bathroom sink too high I like a shower not a tub shower but only a shower to stand in. get rid of the tub.
HOWARD




Hampton Inn Long Island / Commack
Hampton Inn Long Island / CommackCommack
10/10 Excellent
Customer service is top notch.
The lady at the front desk is reallly knowledgeable.
The facilities are clean and well maintained for the age of the building.
I recommend this hotel.
Thanks to all the people involved in delivering an excellent customer service!
Customer service is top notch.
The lady at the front desk is reallly knowledgeable.
The facilities are clean and well maintained for the age of the building.
I recommend this hotel.
Thanks to all the people involved in delivering an excellent customer service!
WILLIAM




Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End by IHG
Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End by IHGRiverhead
10/10 Excellent
comfortable and relaxed stay. Rooms are nice and spacious and has a great big TV inside. The room also has a microwave and refrigerator. Everything you could need out of a hotel room.
comfortable and relaxed stay. Rooms are nice and spacious and has a great big TV inside. The room also has a microwave and refrigerator. Everything you could need out of a hotel room.
Steven





