Find Hotels with a Pool in Fire Island, NY

"It’s a beautiful property where the rooms are kept very clean. The bar and restaurant are terrific. The bar was opened until 1am on the weekends. The big downside was all the stains on chairs and couches. It looks ewww and I didn’t want to sit on any of that. Quite gross. Otherwise everything was great "

"The pool was amazing the room was not amazing clean "

"Very clean and comfortable a little slamming doors you would hear but "

"The hot tub was closed at 10pm on a Friday which was unfortunate."

"Elevator was broken. While the staff was courteous and friendly having our 80 year old Mom walk up 2 flights of stairs was terrible. "

"Clean rooms"

"Great "

"Didn’t make up the room when asked "

"I choose this hotel above others in the area that were less expensive because they said they had 24/7 food available. They did not. The staff stood directly beneath the sign on their wall that said "24/7 food available" and said the kitchen closed at 7. I asked another staff member why they didn't have food available and she just shrugged. I'm assuming it is a question they get a lot: I saw a family leaving the next day complaining they had to go to a different hotel to get dinner. "