Find Hotels with a Pool in Fire Island, NY

"Staff was accommodating for early check in and late checkout "

"Good hotel for the area. Looks a bit old and may require an upgrade soon but overalll is very clean, staff is excellent. I'd stay again if I come back"

"Not used."

"Fast wifi, friendly staff, great services, quiet "

"Understaffed. Smells funky. Cold pool. AC unit in room did not work. Went to the desk to ask for help. There is never actually anyone at the front desk. Was told maintenance would be up to help. This was at 10.30 at night. No one came so by 11 I went to the front desk to ask for a new room. I can’t sleep in a room where the temp is 79 degrees. We were given a new room one floor up. When we got all of our stuff up there we settled in for the early morning. Went to the bathroom and found a friend in the tub. Once one friend is found I cannot sleep so we checked out and were in a new hotel by 12:30 am."

"I have stayed here multiple times and the experience has not been much different. The front desk staff is typically unfriendly and unable to help with minor issues. Check in took nearly 15 minutes for a prepaid room. The room itself is fine and serves its purpose. "

"One of the best places to stay when on the Island."

"It's ok for the price. Don't expect much. Ask for a room with no carpet. Breakfast is definitely continental, we didn't even eat there. "

"We only stayed for one night the rom was clean the area seemed safe and very vibrant with plenty of shops and restaurants to choose from. "