Find Hotels with a Pool in Fire Island, NY

"Excellent all around "

"No"

"Clean facilities, very friendly staff, and a good breakfast. My only criticism is that the signage directing to the hotel could be better."

"We had a terrible experience at the Hilton this past Saturday evening. It was like staying in a frat house. Adults running up and down the hall, slamming doors, blasting music. Front desk staff told us, "I mean, it's a Saturday night". There's a giant sign next to the elevators saying quiet hours are from 10pm to 7am. We experienced someone having a full on rave in their room well past 1am. We begged to switch rooms, and were told there was nothing available, however once my husband really lost his temper (at 130am), suddenly there was an empty room available on the other side of the hotel. We packed up our whole room and moved in the middle of the night. Truly horrible night and we will never return."

"It was average hotel"

"Very clean plenty of space and very quiet hotel."

"A very nice and welcoming hotel Friendly staff and spacious rooms Breakfast was very good"

"The hotel was rundown, but it looked like they might be making improvements in the future."

"Worst hotel I’ve ever stayed at in my life"