Search Plum Island Cottages

Bundle & Save

Get more, spend less whenever you see Bundle & Save deals

OneKeyCash

Earn OneKeyCash on all your eligible bookings

Upfront pricing

We are not like the others - we include taxes and fees

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Cottages in Plum Island

Our top choices for Plum Island cottages

"Price was great"

"This was perfection!! Immaculate close to the beach and just charming!! Will absolutely stay again!!!! "

"Great property, great location and wonderful owner!"

"Very clean, and comfortable stay. Gorgeous location!"

$412 nightly

Sep 14 - Sep 15

Total with taxes and fees

"Nice and close to the beach! House is clean and nicely decorated."

"The owners were helpful and very friendly! The cottage was great and had even more than we expected. Close to the beach and downtown. "

"We enjoyed our stay. The hosts thought of everything."

"Everything was absolutely perfect! We couldn’t have asked for a better place! The place was super clean ,comfortable and conveniently located. But , Angelica , the host was extremely helpful with places to eat and things to do . We can’t wait to come back. You won’t ever be disappointed if you stay here. "

"We were staying close for a family birthday party. It was walking distance to downtown Belmar. Kelli & Jim the hosts were very nice and helpful. It was perfect for our long weekend and very comfortable. "

"Awesome time with Awesome people, friends, family. Great food!!"

"Adorable place! It was clean and the host provided everything you needed for a cozy stay. The host provided clear instructions which made for a very easy stay. I would return myself and recommend to others!"

"While surprisingly far away from Asbury Park, location turned out great for departure Tuesday morning. Best feature was three bedrooms, so couple could have one room, and each teen could have another. Also great: two bathrooms. Not air conditioned, but fans adequate this late in season, plus close to ocean. Was hard to figure out parking. Having ginger ale as well as water in fridge a nice touch. But no pillow cases on pillows, just shams. Even after we called to inquire, the "welcomer" said he...

"Excellent property and the owner is very nice! We were visiting from Texas and never have been to Long Beach before. Its only about a 45 minute from New York City and love being able to visit New York City and then get some peace and quiet from that busy city. The location of the home is perfect and can walk to the beach about two blocks away. There is a laundry mat around the corner and can knock out your laundry fast. Also tons of restaurants around that are all mom and pop run and the...