Find all hotels by Red Roof Inn in Plum Island, NJ from $96

"Initially concerned that room was too tight/small, but it grew on us. Very efficient use of space. Might be problem for anyone with mobility issues due to tight spacing of bed. Very comfortable bed & best shower I’ve ever used( amazing water pressure and shower head. "

"Clean room "

"The service was phenomenal. Everyone went out of the way to ensure we had a nice time. Beds were comfortable. Great location. Hotel rooms needed update. Toilet ran constantly and every now and then we had an unpleasant sewage smell. "

"I had a wonderful stay, The location is perfect close to great restaurants, the subway, and the waterfront. The staff were warm and professional, and the room was spotless and comfortable. It felt modern yet welcoming. I’d definitely stay here again"

"Cute hotel room, smaller than the photos, attentive staff and great bars around ; octoberfest was a cool experience! "

"Did not offer a view. of the city."

"Love it"

"Temperature was comfortable. Staff was very accommodating and responded to requests quickly. "

"Beautiful place. Helpful staff. Breakfast was hot and lots of verity. "