Find Hotels with a Pool in Shelter Island, NY

"Beautiful room right across from the ocean and by town. Definitely go back!"

"wonderful place only criticism is how far away rooms are from lobby and the rest of the facilities"

"Perfect location!"

"Liked having and using pool. didn't realize there would be a swimming lesson going on at same time. As this was a quick stop over on our way to Bar Harbor, it fit our needs. Since the room was on the street side it was a bit noisy even with fan running all the time. The room was clean and comfortable and we enjoyed the breakfast which was included. "

"Beautiful grounds and quiet private beach"

"Loved everything about this property. Location, Staff, Amenities. Decor and furniture beautiful. "

"Locations are d writhing, and the marran has this, right on the beach, watching whales, dolphins and spinning sharks from the comfort of the pool and/or beach…… lovely sitting area for drinks and dinner watching the sun go down. This is a hotel to savour on a nice night, we stayed the 18/19 sept, 2025! One thing that was a shock, no TV in room and little hanging space for clothes, so if you can manage around that (as we did) The other odd point and the reason for my low score on Eco friendly, is the hotels use of plastic fork, knives and spoons, and plastic cups which in this day goes against the grain, so that aside if you want a modern hotel in a great location thus is a must……. And one, that we would go back too."

"This property was BEAUTIFUL! The checkin was perfect. Our room was ready before 1 pm. The views were spectacular. The staff was so friendly. The property was manicured and comfortable. I will be coming back!!!"

"Wonderful hotel and location "