Search Guest Houses in Shelter Island Heights

"We were wondering what this place would be like but it far exceeded any expectations we had. The property is well maintained, service was great, and our cottage was clean & comfy. Would definitely stay here again! "

"Amazing location. Lovely lake. Serene and Tranquil experience. "

"Visited in May 2024 - this is a wonderful, clean, stay in a second-floor carriage house, literally a stone's throw from a private sandy beach. Fully stocked kitchen, laundry, with convenient beach chairs and umbrellas, toys for the kids. WiFi is spotty, but who wants to do work when the beach is across the street?!? Highly recommended!"

"Nice"

"My husband and I brought our rescue dog Beau with us. One of the few places found that allow dogs. We all had a great time. Bar and restaurant on the property. Nicely appointed room. The most comfortable king bed we ever slept in away from home. Loved it and we will return soon."

"The place is adorable and steps to the ocean with a gorgeous view of the water and sunrise. We had a fantastic time!"

"Best affordable hotel in Montauk"

"Good family friendly resort! Hope it’s a heated pool.. Easy Check-out before 11:00 am!"

"Very nice location and nice condo"