$66 Car Rental Fire Island, NY

Search and Compare from Car Companies in Fire Island

Photo by Carole Polney
I have a discount code

Featured car rental suppliers

Compare from agencies

car suppliers logo

Change your mind: penalty-free cancellation on many/select car rentals

Treat yourself: One Key members save 10% or more on over 1 million car rentals

Shop Smart: Compare car suppliers and package your flight, hotel, and car to save

Top Car Deals in Fire Island

* Price found within the past 6 days. Click for updated prices.

Tue, Aug 5 to Wed, Aug 6

Compact

Nissan Versa Note or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Nissan Versa Note

$66

includes taxes & fees
$51 per day
found 8 hours ago
Compact Nissan Versa Note
Tue, Aug 5 to Wed, Aug 6

Special

Wild Card Compact or larger if available or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York City, New York, USA
Wild Card Compact or larger if available

$74

includes taxes & fees
$51 per day
found 8 hours ago
Special Wild Card Compact or larger if available
Tue, Aug 5 to Wed, Aug 6

Midsize

Toyota Corolla or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Toyota Corolla

$67

includes taxes & fees
$52 per day
found 8 hours ago
Midsize Toyota Corolla
Tue, Aug 5 to Wed, Aug 6

Economy

Ford Fiesta or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Ford Fiesta

$68

includes taxes & fees
$53 per day
found 8 hours ago
Economy Ford Fiesta
Tue, Aug 5 to Wed, Aug 6

Standard

Volkswagen Jetta or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Volkswagen Jetta

$70

includes taxes & fees
$54 per day
found 8 hours ago
Standard Volkswagen Jetta
Tue, Aug 5 to Wed, Aug 6

Fullsize

Nissan Altima or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Nissan Altima

$75

includes taxes & fees
$58 per day
found 8 hours ago
Fullsize Nissan Altima
Mon, Aug 4 to Tue, Aug 5

Midsize Elite

Tesla Short Range Model 3 or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Jamaica, New York, USA
Tesla Short Range Model 3

$87

includes taxes & fees
$62 per day
found 4 hours ago
Midsize Elite Tesla Short Range Model 3
Tue, Aug 5 to Wed, Aug 6

Standard Elite Special

Ford Mustang Mach-E or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Jamaica, New York, USA
Ford Mustang Mach-E

$92

includes taxes & fees
$66 per day
found 7 hours ago
Standard Elite Special Ford Mustang Mach-E
Tue, Aug 5 to Wed, Aug 6

Fullsize Elite Pickup Regular Cab

RAM 2500 or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
RAM 2500

$103

includes taxes & fees
$72 per day
found 8 hours ago
Fullsize Elite Pickup Regular Cab RAM 2500
Mon, Aug 4 to Tue, Aug 5

Premium Special

Audi A3 or BMW 2 Series Gran Coupe or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
JAMAICA, USA
Audi A3 or BMW 2 Series Gran Coupe

$144

includes taxes & fees
$102 per day
found 2 hours ago
Premium Special Audi A3 or BMW 2 Series Gran Coupe
Mon, Aug 4 to Tue, Aug 5

Luxury

Audi A4 or BMW 3 Series or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York City, New York, USA
Audi A4 or BMW 3 Series

$149

includes taxes & fees
$105 per day
found 4 hours ago
Luxury Audi A4 or BMW 3 Series
Mon, Aug 4 to Tue, Aug 5

Compact Elite Crossover

Volvo XC40 Hybrid or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Volvo XC40 Hybrid

$148

includes taxes & fees
$107 per day
found 6 hours ago
Compact Elite Crossover Volvo XC40 Hybrid
Mon, Aug 4 to Tue, Aug 5

Luxury Elite

Genesis G80E or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Jamaica, New York, USA
Genesis G80E

$166

includes taxes & fees
$121 per day
found 5 hours ago
Luxury Elite Genesis G80E
Wed, Aug 6 to Thu, Aug 7

Premium Elite Crossover

Cadillac XT6 or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York City, New York, USA
Cadillac XT6

$205

includes taxes & fees
$150 per day
found 4 hours ago
Premium Elite Crossover Cadillac XT6
Wed, Aug 6 to Thu, Aug 7

Mini Van

Chrysler Pacifica or similar
  • 7 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York City, New York, USA
Chrysler Pacifica

$216

includes taxes & fees
$154 per day
found 3 hours ago
Mini Van Chrysler Pacifica

Don't see what you're looking for?

See all car rentals in Fire Island
View all cars
Lowest prices found within the past 8 hours. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Frequently asked questions

How much is a rental car per day on Fire Island?
Daily rental prices were as low as $66 within the past seven days. With deals like this, cruising around Fire Island in your own ride is an affordable way to explore its sights.
What happens if I need to cancel my Fire Island car reservation?
That won't be a problem. If you cancel your prepaid booking at least six hours prior to the pickup time, you'll most likely receive a full refund. You'll want to scan your cancellation policy as there are some exclusions. Hop on our Customer Service Portal for more info.
What types of cars can I rent on Fire Island?
Compact, mid-size or full-size ... Pick up the keys to whatever you prefer! Economy is the most sought-after rental vehicle category on Fire Island. Small, with superb fuel-efficiency and a joy to handle, these rides make driving around enjoyable. Maybe best of all? Your wallet will love them. That means you'll have more money to spend on other things, like exploring as much of this wonderful island as you can.
What are the top things to do on Fire Island?
There are so many things to see and do on and around Fire Island. And when you collect the keys to your rental car, you can discover them all at your convenience. You'll want to add these well-known spots to your must-do list:

  • The kids are sure to sleep soundly after playing by the seaside at Ocean Beach. Hunt for pretty seashore treasures, stick a toe in the water or throw a Frisbee around!
  • Fire Island Lighthouse was erected to help sailors navigate through rough waters. Still an important local landmark today, it's bound to have some stories to tell about sailing adventures and tragedies.
  • A prominent landmark that's withstood the test of time, you can't miss Robert Moses Water Tower. It's a notable attraction for history enthusiasts and regular visitors alike.

Why should I rent a Fire Island car with Expedia?
There are plenty of reasons to book your rental with Expedia. We have suppliers to select from on Fire Island, and we'll find you the best deal with our exclusive offers and member prices. Love to save even more? Bundle your rental car, flights and hotels into a vacation package. The more you travel and book with Expedia, the bigger the benefits!
How do I find the best car rental deals on Fire Island with Expedia?
Whatever kind of wheels you're looking for, Expedia will help you score the best deal. Simply compare offers from well-known rental providers and select the option that suits you. Love to hit the road with even more in your wallet? Combine your Fire Island car rental with flight or hotel bookings.
How old do you have to be to rent a car on Fire Island?
At least 21 years of age. Tripping around in a rental car is the best way to see Fire Island, but take note that an additional daily fee generally applies to younger drivers. A higher age limit also often applies to the rental of luxury or extra large vehicles. Be sure to have a good read over the fine print before choosing your wheels.
What do you need to rent a car on Fire Island?
Renting a ride on Fire Island requires a full, valid driver's license and a credit card in your name. If you'd like to opt out of the rental supplier's insurance plan, you're likely to need your own proof of coverage. Read through the terms and conditions of your policy to save any hassles at pickup.
What is the cheapest car rental on Fire Island?
The lowest rate for a rental car within the past seven days on Fire Island was $66 per day. The next best deal was $67. When it comes to reliable, affordable vehicles, you can't beat Expedia.
Can I rent a car for a month or longer on Fire Island?
Yes, you can explore the incredible scenery of Fire Island for a month or more in one of our rentals. Just enter your travel dates and pickup and drop-off locations, and we'll find you the best long-term car rental deals around.
Where can I find a Fire Island car rental if I am younger than 25?
If you're under 25, renting a car on Fire Island will depend on the age policies of the available rental providers. Be mindful that a young renter surcharge is often applied if you're between 21 and 24 years old, and you may be limited to certain car classes. Spend time going through the fine print so there are no unwelcome surprises at the rental desk.
What insurance should I choose for my car rental on Fire Island?
Before you start exploring the wonders of Fire Island, you'll want to have a comprehensive insurance plan. That's why adding Expedia's collision protection to your rental is a smart move. This covers collision damage, theft and vandalism and can be added easily when you book your ride. You'll also have round-the-clock emergency help, a zero-dollar deductible and primary coverage, so you won't need to claim on your regular insurance.

Car Rental Information

 
Popular car types
SUV, Full Size, Economy
 
Car suppliers available
 
Our best deal of the day
$66
 
Our second best deal of the day
$67
 
Our third best deal of the day
$68
 
From the airport to your hotel
Airport Transportation
 
From popular domestic and international airports
Airport Car Rentals

Finding the cheapest car rentals in Fire Island

Using our Search Wizard

If the deals that are available on our page do not suit your needs, then enter Fire Island into the search wizard at the top of the page. We will compare all the best deals available for your car rental in Fire Island and provide you with a list of the cheapest options, with no added fees.

Renting a car in Fire Island

Pay at pickup is available, so you don’t have to worry about spending your money until you arrive at your vehicle in Fire Island. We partner with reliable partners that guarantee an enjoyable experience for solo travelers, couples, and families. Package your car with a flight or hotel to unlock even more savings from Expedia.

Expected prices in Fire Island

Prices are subject to seasonal change depending on when you decide to arrange your car rental but right now you can book from $66.

Flexibility & Cancellation

Most car suppliers offer penalty-free cancellations, so you don’t have to worry about losing money if your plans change. To cancel your booking log into your account through the Trips portal. Click manage booking and cancel this car. If you needed to alter your booking, then you can create a new one once you have canceled.

We all love being rewarded

One Key members save 10% or more on select hotels, cars, activities and vacation rentals. Not only that, earn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible hotels, vacation rentals, flights, car rentals, and more when you book across our family of brands: Expedia, Hotels.com and VRBO. Learn more and join today.

Car classes available from Expedia in 2025

The classes of vehicles available will change depending on your chosen location.