Romantic Hotels in St. Peter from $168

"…"

"True luxury and amazing place to stay"

"Stayed here for a week in April 2026. Very clean, with easy access to West side of the island for beaches and restaurants Loved the three separate bathrooms, which worked perfect for our company. Jacqui was great and very responsive to any questions. "

"Better than the pictures and description on VRBO. Only 1 minor issue with Beach towels not completely replaced after 2nd cleaning but not a big deal."

"It was a beautiful space in a nice quiet neighborhood. Centrally located and a perfect fit for our family!"

"Fantastic stay and lovely host!! "

"My family of 12 stayed at the Old Sugar House from April 2-7. The house is soooo beautiful, clean and spacious. The pictures do not do it justice at all. The garden and views are breathtaking. Short drive to beautiful beaches. It was so easy communicating with Sue,she was always quick to reply, very pleasant, patient with my many questions and made some great suggestions in preparation for our arrival. The staff is an added bonus that made our vacation a true vacation. They are all so lovely. We did not have to lift a finger. Bibi made sure the house was spotlessly clean, beds made, laundry done. Terry is a fabulous chef who prepared meals with love and catered to those with various food allergies. Wendell made the best rum punch and was available for anything we needed. Thank you Old Sugar House for the memories our family will never forget!! We will be back for sure!!"

"A wonderful place. Just the perfect size, beautiful, clean and comfortable. The 4pm afternoon tea is a plus. I recommend highly"

"Amazing stay! Very clean, great communications and everything we needed was there. Could not recommend this place more!"