Find Hotels with a Pool in Salt Cay

"Bring your wallet! $1000 hold placed on credit card for incidentals and they are completely cashless. Don’t get much sleep because the first night the dishwasher beeped all night and had to call the front desk. The next night had to call again because the sprinkler was vibrating so loudly that it woke us up. It could be heard when my husband called the front desk. The response was swift but it was distracting. Overall, it was a nice resort and we enjoyed ourselves."

"If you are going to the Bahamas this is the place to stay"

"As a Choice Hotels Gold Member, I always have high expectations when staying within the brand family, but the Comfort Suites Paradise Island truly blew me away. From start to finish, this stay was absolutely seamless. During our stay we interacted with various team members whose level of professionalism and warmth made us feel like valued guests. They were friendly, welcoming, and went out of their way to ensure everything was perfect. Our room was the ideal home base. It was perfectly sized, thoughtfully laid out and had everything we needed to feel at home. It was clean, comfortable, and provided the perfect retreat after a long day in the sun. The pool was absolutely perfect for evening dips and lounging, and the poolside landscaping made you feel like you were on a beach! The breakfast was hot, fresh, and ready every morning - scrambled or hard boiled eggs, bacon, sausage, waffles, toast, fresh fruit, oatmeal, cereal, juice, coffee, tea - they had it all! You can't beat the convenience of this hotel. It is a two minute walk to Atlantis, there is a restaurant across the street and a grocery store around the corner, for stocking up! Choice Hotels remains my preference for a reason, and this property is a shining example of why. I will definitely be back!"

"Our room was clean, the food/drinks were good and the amenities were fab! "

"All the staff and especially the front desk manager were very helpful and welcoming."

"The whole property smelled of raw sewage. The pool chairs were hard with no cushions. Food was mediocre at best. Our room ceiling started leaking and had to be moved to another room. All inclusive was not entirely true. Ice cream you had to buy. If you wanted an in room fridge, you had to rent it extra $. Bad experience overall."

"Beautifully decorated resort. So much to do! Expensive food & beverages but overall such a great resort!"

"Atlantis is such a magical resort. Would definitely return. "

"We have always loved staying at the Cove and have been coming here since it first opened. First, the Cove pool is closed (relocated to a previously vacant pool area) until December. We were not informed of this prior to booking.At check-in at the hotel we were still not informed about the pool closure, nor that work was being done on the Cove rooms Monday through Saturday 8am-6pm. They also did not inform us that both poolside restaurants at the Reef and the Cove were also closed. Not only did we have to find this all out on our own, once we did find out and contacted the front desk staff, they offered no compensation in room upgrade, decreased pricing, or any type of “perk” to correct the situation for disgruntled frequently returning guests. Additionally, once at the “relocated pool” location, the nearest woman’s restroom was a 10 minute walk away to the children’s pool. These restrooms were always out of toilet paper, showed no sign of maintenance, and many of the stall doors didn’t even lock. For those traveling with young children, the absence of door locks on bathroom stalls would alarm me. The Cove remodeling could have gone much better if it had been better-planned, and guests were alerted with some good PR prior to the remodel. Upgrades, discounts, and offering perks (free water and soda to start would have been nice), and a lot better customer service, would have gone a long way!!"