Search Sheffield Cottages

"Breakfast was awesome"

"This historic inn is beautiful! We stayed in the main building which was built around 1760. The room was very spacious and set up well. We also had an enclosed 'porch' which was very nice. There was a small refrigerator. A microwave and coffee maker were not in the room. That would have been nice. The bathroom was also spacious, but had a lot of wasted space. It could have been arranged better, giving a larger shower area. The heat is the old, stand-up radiator/building heat, so there is not much ability to control the room's temperature accurately. The first night was too warm, second too cool, etc. The best part about staying here was the staff and the breakfast. The staff was fantastic and always available if you needed. They were always pleasant and ready to help. Joe, Lucas and (I don't know the lady's name) were great! Especially Joe! I always had the omelet for breakfast. It was probably the best I've ever had. There was also a good sized fruit cup, home fries, toast or English muffin and pancakes. Coffee, juice, and, of course, water were also provided. Coffee, tea and cookies were always available in the foyer. The cookies seemed home-made and not store bought. Very good. Even though we stayed 4 nights, our room was made up every day with fresh towels and linens. A few pieces of candy were also set on a tray. Nice. We stayed here due to the proximity to Canaan. We would definitely stay here again if visiting that area. Rated Excellent primarily due to staff."

"Solid location, great room, good breakfast. Fair Price. Been 3 different times and look forward to returning again "

"The room was great, with a balcony and indoor fireplace. The lake was beautiful, renting a kayak and exploring made for a great morning. The surrounding areas made things even more enjoyable, providing great hiking and scenery "

"The staff was amazing, so kind and accommodating. The room was clean, the beds were very comfortable. Nice breakfast options. We were in town for a concert at Mahaiwe and we didn’t use our car once we checked in… a great home base for the weekend. Will definitely be back. "

"Very friendly and accommodating staff. Room was clean, which is very important to us. Breakfast in the morning was great. Nice variety of items and nice and fresh. It saved us money and the hassles of finding a breakfast restaurant. We are very pleased with our stay. "

"I love the ambience - historic and comfortable and excellent food. "

"Everything was so perfect for a weekend to just get away and decompress, the staff were great, the room was awesome. "

"Very pleasant staff, clean, bright condo, comfortable bed & linens. Kitchen has all the basic supplies. The front office gave us coffee filters since the included packaged coffee was very weak, but we always bring our own coffee for backup. The activity center is large, clean and has many fun amenities. The fitness room is good , 2 large indoor pool with adjacent hot tubs. The tiles of one hot tub could use some cleaning (like most hotels!) but otherwise good. The chemical levels /odors were not overwhelming. A guest above our first floor unit walked very heavy late in the evening but the noise didn't last too long. We enjoyed our stay at a very reasonable cost during the off season !"