Search Inns in Shelter Island

"This is a great place to stay with an outstanding location in Old Saybrook right on RT 1. Great breakfast cafe right across the street."

"My family and I stayed at Offshore Montauk and it was just perfect! The rooms were great, the staff were extremely accommodating, we were able to check-in earlier than we thought. Once I told them I was expecting family members, they were quick to try accommodating for us to be near each other. The pool area was clean, music was nice, the hotel is located walking-distance to many shops and restaurants plus like 2 minute-walk to the beach, literally across the street! I would recommend this hotel to anyone planning Montauk this summer "

"We love this hotel "

"This was such a nice location, and fair price for what you get. I would stay here again no problem. "

"My husband and I loved the Quality Inn. The only problem was we could not get the shower to work."

"We had a view of the water and the staff was very welcoming and the place was very clean when we arrived and even though check in was 4 we received an email at 12:30 that our room was ready even though the weather was rainy and cloudy for the whole weekend we still made the best of it."

"We were able to check in early. Nice staff "

"Fantastic Historical value Br"

"Gorgeous stay on a girls trip"