Find Sugarcreek motels from $72

"This was our first stay at the Carlisle Inn, and we will be returning again in the near future. Our room was extremely clean and it was very quiet. If you need rest this is the place you need. I would encourage everyone to check this place out. The staff is friendly and helpful. Love the breakfast, and the snacks at night."

"Hotel was excellent. Well maintained. Perfect for our girls trip to Amish country. Super walkable location. Included breakfast was great with many options. Would definitely stay here again."

"Staff was very friendly and helpful/efficient. The breakfast buffet had many hot items and was very tasty. Will stay there again. Highly recommend."

"Treated like family when we were there!"

"E everything was excellent except breakfast which was premade and packaged omelets hash browns sausage that were frozen. With directions to heat them n microwave. Also offered cereal and juice. Not good at all, e were very disappointed in this . Being a diabetic nothing was really appealing. Probably would think other options before rebooking for this one thing only"

"Checking in was easy, staff was friendly, room was clean, bed was comfortable, it was nice to have a balcony this time, the campus is always well kept and inviting with varying places to sit, fire pits and patio lighting was cozy, breakfast is served nice an early, a lot of variety, the pool was nice, stays available late I do go for a swim at 10pm, encounters with staff we’re all friendly and kind. I would like to thank the staff member unsure of her name but she remembered me and that had I tried to extend my stay Friday into Saturday but there were no rooms available which also goes to show you how nice the hotel is that it is always booked up, but she found my cell number and called me while I had already checked out and was shopping locally there was a room that came available I didn’t take the reservation because the rate was more for the one night then I had spent for the previous nights again not anything she could have done but I thank you for going above and beyond!!"

"Clean and quiet "

"The hotel staff was kind and professional!"

"Yes, the breakfast was very good, especially the biscuits and gravy..."