Find hotels near Theater of the Sea, Islamorada from $144

Search over 1 million properties and 550 airlines worldwide.

Save 10% or more on select stays with Expedia Rewards

Most hotels are fully refundable. Because flexibility matters.

Top Hotels Close to Theater of the Sea

Coconut Cove Resort and Marina
2.5 out of 5
0.091 mi from Theater of the Sea
The price is $159 per night from Dec 5 to Dec 5
3.3/5 (351 reviews)
"Beautiful relaxing scenery and great pool specially for little ones."

Reviewed on Nov 28, 2021

Coconut Cove Resort and Marina
Fisher Inn Resort & Marina
3.5 out of 5
0.3 mi from Theater of the Sea
The price is $144 per night from Dec 14 to Dec 14
3.4/5 (985 reviews)
"The resort was clean and new. We loved keeping the boat in the water for ease of use. Rooms were well appointed and comfortable with ocean views. We will be back!"

Reviewed on Nov 4, 2021

Fisher Inn Resort & Marina
Pelican Cove Resort & Marina
3 out of 5
0.3 mi from Theater of the Sea
Fully refundableReserve now, pay when you stay
The price is $268 per night from Dec 7 to Dec 7
4.2/5 Excellent! (987 reviews)
"We liked the Sunset view from our large balcony. Parking is plentiful. Signage for amenities/ stairwells/elevators could have been better. Convienent dining options on site. Pool was nice, but plenty of beach chairs though smallish beach area. ch"

Reviewed on Dec 1, 2021

Pelican Cove Resort & Marina
You could be seeing lower prices

You could be seeing lower prices

With member prices, you could save 10% or more right now on thousands of properties.
Drop Anchor
3 out of 5
0.4 mi from Theater of the Sea
The price is $199 per night from Dec 5 to Dec 5
4.4/5 Wonderful! (982 reviews)
"Great location!"

Reviewed on Nov 24, 2021

Drop Anchor
Single Family Home In Angler's Reef Gated Community, Beaches,Marina,Heated Pool
4.9/5 Exceptional! (63 reviews)
The house was as pictured. Very nice
"Enjoyed our stay. Any questions we had were answered right away."

Reviewed on Nov 23, 2021

Single Family Home In Angler's Reef Gated Community, Beaches,Marina,Heated Pool
Caribbean Villa in Islamorada Resort Community with Dedicated Boat Slip
5/5 Exceptional! (7 reviews)
Great villa in a wonderful setting
"Anglers Reef is a lovely community, the pool is great and the villa is perfect. It was our 2nd time at Anglers Reef, 1st time at this villa. The villa was clean and had everything we needed. Dom was great to communicate with, he responded very quickly whenever we had a question. Would recommend staying ..."

Reviewed on Feb 24, 2020

Caribbean Villa in Islamorada Resort Community with Dedicated Boat Slip
Luxurious Home at beautiful Anglers Reef with Boat Slip available
5/5 Exceptional! (69 reviews)
Great Vacation Location and Home
"Jo was wonderful to work with. Communication was top notch! Check in was so easy. Jo was most accommodating with our requests. I would highly recommend staying in this cute house and enjoying all it has to offer. We loved the access to the boat dock the most."

Reviewed on Sep 29, 2021

Luxurious Home at beautiful Anglers Reef with Boat Slip available
Beautiful Water Front in Angler's Reef with View of Sand Bar with Boat Slip
4.9/5 Exceptional! (49 reviews)
Wonderful birthday vacation
"We had a wonderful time celebrating my two birthdays - my 50th and my brother-in-laws 44th. The property was beautiful and the house was very cozy. We had all the comforts of home with a killer view of the water. Our only regret was that we had to leave a day early due to the uncertainty of travel ..."

Reviewed on Nov 11, 2020

Beautiful Water Front in Angler's Reef with View of Sand Bar with Boat Slip
Single Family Home In Angler's Reef Gated Community,Beautiful Ground,Resort Pool
4.9/5 Exceptional! (71 reviews)
We really enjoyed this unit and complex. The washer wasn’t working but owner communicated great
"This unit is well appointed, clean and worked out great for our family. The unit doesn’t have any ocean views (if trees were trimmed you’d have a slight one), but you are very close to pool and ocean. Really enjoyed our stay here."

Reviewed on Oct 24, 2021

Single Family Home In Angler's Reef Gated Community,Beautiful Ground,Resort Pool
Islamorada Oceanfront Home In Anglers Reef Ocean Views, Dock, Comm Pool & Beach
5/5 Exceptional! (62 reviews)
Great fall break vacation!
"Perfect vacation! We rented the Salty Pelican for a week during our daughters fall break. The location was perfect. Right on the water with many activities near by and a great community pool. Scott was great to work with. Communication was awesome and was available to answer any questions we had ..."

Reviewed on Oct 19, 2021

Islamorada Oceanfront Home In Anglers Reef Ocean Views, Dock, Comm Pool & Beach
Angler's Reef Resort by KeysCaribbean
3.5 out of 5
0.5 mi from Theater of the Sea
4.7/5 Exceptional! (12 reviews)
"The pool and the beach are incredible. Great place to stay. Great family vacation spot."

Reviewed on Mar 14, 2021

Angler's Reef Resort by KeysCaribbean
Spectacular Ocean Front Home In Beautiful Islamorada!<br>Dock,Com Pool, & Prv Beach
5/5 Exceptional! (2 reviews)
Excellent stay!!
"We absolutely loved staying in this neighborhood! Convenient location to everything whether in the water or near restaurants. The home is immaculate! The owners are very accommodating and right around the corner if you need anything! Would absolutely stay here again next time!!"

Reviewed on Aug 15, 2021

Spectacular Ocean Front Home In Beautiful Islamorada!<br>Dock,Com Pool, & Prv Beach
Anglers Reef Premium Villa
Anglers Reef Islamorada  home with ocean views, private marina, beach & pool
5/5 Exceptional! (26 reviews)
Best vacation ever!!!! 🏖☀️👙❤️🚤
"This is the best vacation rental experience we have had to date. The entire property is well manicured, amenities are well maintained, and its in a great location on Islamorada. You are walking distance to some great food and around the channel to the marina. Not to mention there are two great sandbars ..."

Reviewed on Oct 19, 2021

Anglers Reef Islamorada home with ocean views, private marina, beach & pool
Welcome to Paradise "Sandbar Bungalow Villa" @ Anglers Reef
4.9/5 Exceptional! (78 reviews)
A quick get away…
"Spent a great week in this unit…the weather wasn’t very cooperative but the unit was! It had everything we needed to deal with the weather!"

Reviewed on Nov 20, 2021

Welcome to Paradise "Sandbar Bungalow Villa" @ Anglers Reef
Anglers Reef Villa 1
3.5 out of 5
0.5 mi from Theater of the Sea
4.7/5 Exceptional! (3 reviews)
"The property is centrally located, so it's very easy to get to all of the keys. The layout is excellent and is very well stocked with everything you will need. The pool on the property is fantastic with a great view. Communication with the owner is fantastic. We would definitely go here again and ..."

Reviewed on Nov 14, 2018

Anglers Reef Villa 1
Anglers Reef Premier Villa
0.5 mi from Theater of the Sea
5/5 Exceptional! (1 review)
Great place to stay
"We loved the open layout and the 2 floor townhouse. It is walking distance to Hog Heaven, which has great conch chowder and ribs! Perfect location and very clean house."

Reviewed on Oct 30, 2018

Anglers Reef Premier Villa
Pristine Pool Front Anglers Reef  w/ Ocean Views, Private Beach & Dock
5/5 Exceptional! (1 review)
Paradise!
"We could not be more satisfied with every aspect of this vacation location. Loved the gorgeous well equiped home, fantastic views, excellent fishing, convenience of walkable restaurants, bait & tackle and short drive to grocery store. Great owner! Property very well kept & managed. Can't wait to ..."

Reviewed on Nov 12, 2021

Pristine Pool Front Anglers Reef w/ Ocean Views, Private Beach & Dock
Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina
3 out of 5
0.5 mi from Theater of the Sea
Fully refundableReserve now, pay when you stay
The price is $276 per night from Dec 15 to Dec 15
4.4/5 Wonderful! (1,044 reviews)
"This is a great centrally located property in the middle of the keys. Very nice hotel...have stayed here several times. the main pool needs some attention. Lots of missing tiles and somewhat dirty. Property is very nice, for the price...the pool should be kept nicer. We'll definitely stay here ..."

Reviewed on Dec 2, 2021

Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina
Chesapeake Beach Resort
2.5 out of 5
1.1 mi from Theater of the Sea
Fully refundableReserve now, pay when you stay
The price is $189 per night from Dec 5 to Dec 5
3.7/5 Good! (958 reviews)
"I have been going to The Chesapeake for over 20 years and I have enjoyed every minute of each stay!! I love the remodeling of the property, although they are still remodeling the cottages which really doesn’t affect the hotel. I highly recommend this place!!!"

Reviewed on Nov 29, 2021

Chesapeake Beach Resort
Don't see what you're looking for?
See all available properties in Theater of the Sea
View all properties
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Frequently asked questions

Recent reviews of Theater of the Sea hotels
expedia verified reviews