The Best Newcastle, WY Chalets

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Chalets in Newcastle

"The hosts of the Blue Birds nest are super friendly and helpful. The place was super cute and perfect for our groups to stay in. Would definitely stay again."

"Perfect for a ski weekend "

"We really enjoyed our stay! The listing was very accurate, cabin was clean and we had great communication with hosts. It’s located just outside of Custer which was nice nice not being right in town but still very close. Would definitely recommend staying here and will stay again!"

"We enjoyed our stay at Elk Haven which was conveniently located near Custer and a great central location for all of our activities."

"We have been visiting state and National Parks. This was a wonderful place to stay for 3 nights as we explored all the parks! Great hosts and beautiful little cabin - room to spread out and call home for 3 days! Kitchen had all we needed, cabin was just as described in listing. There’s plenty of room ….super clean and cozy!!!! "

"Loved the cabin and the location"

"We stayed here while exploring the Black Hills and it was a great home base for everywhere we wanted to go. We loved the property, especially the deck!"

"A couple of minor issues upon checking in but were rectified pretty efficiently "

"We had issues from the beginning until the end with this property. The positive thing was that it was so easy to literally hop on the slopes. However it wasn’t enough for me to rent again. The house wasn’t cleaned properly when we arrived, and smelled so gross like wet dirty carpet. The towels were thrown in the cabinet and appeared used. The linens All smelled dirty, like dirty hair. The floor wasn’t vacuumed as there was trash and hair ties right in the middle of the floor. There were no...

"Perfect location and everything on the inside was great! "

"Right up there with the best Vrbo's I've ever stayed in. Perfect place, perfect location, great host."

"Overall a great stay. a light or two that needed new lightbulbs and some dusty services. but loved our stay!"

View all properties

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Sign in

Sign up, it's free

Top Newcastle Hotel Reviews

Comfort Inn & Suites Near Mt. Rushmore

10/10 Excellent

"EXCELLENT property, seemingly secluded yet within a short walk to the wonderful downtown area where it us still 'season,' so everything is open, still. Leave your car parked at hotel, then walk over to 1880 Train-ride to/from Keystone; or, get dinner out at 1885 Steakhouse or Alpine Inn; or, have charcuterie & barrel-dispensed wine at With the Wind winery. EXCELLENT STAFF at desk, and in food prep. for full breakfast at hotel dining area. (I ate egg-omlette on a waffle, and it was great!) EXCELLENT selection of pillows, with very clean linens. Clean hallways, and great room. Ample 'private' parking (at no extra charge)."