Find hotels in Sheffield, PA from $72

"The owner was very nice and was very helpful in all our questions. We had reserved a room which we thought was the main house, but it ended up being in the guest house. We really wanted to stay in the main house. No questions asked, she moved us to the main house with no extra fees. She even gave us a tour of the property and showed us all the amenities. It was an absolutely beautiful room, however the bathroom definitely needs updated and maybe some suggestions will help. I understand they are trying to keep the look and feel of the historic house, but this day in age people want modern comforts. The sink was so small and sprayed water everywhere, and no counter space to put your cosmetics, etc... Turning the hot water on, took forever to get warm. There was shampoo/conditioner and body lotion samples but no shower gel which would have been helpful. The soap bars were almost the size of a quarter. We didn't see any bath mats, so we used our own towels to dry our feet on. The mirrors were so small also and the lighting was very dim. I will also note, this room had 2 beds in it and both beds were way too firm for our liking and the pillows were super thin. But if you like a very firm bed, then it will be great for you. Other then the bathroom experience, the property is gorgeous. We would have loved to have seen a longer time frame for breakfast, like a lot of the hotels 8-10am, but since it was 8-9am off season, we couldn't get down there in time and missed out."

"This place gives off abandoned hotel vibes. The restaurant and bar are been closed for a long time. Yet they sit empty just off the lobby. Pool is open, but I'm not sure I would partake The TV in our room looks like it was bought the yard sale earlier that day. With the remote control that was taped shot with dead batteries in it. The room across the hall looked like the lock had been forcibly removed from the door. There was a hole in bathroom where the wall meets the floor. Not sure what that's a sign of. Spend the extra couple bucks and go up the road to the Hampton Inn"

"Kind of unorthodox but it works! There was no one to greet us upon arrival, we had to call a phone number for an access code to our room. Totally fine, just not the warmest welcome. Notes were left in case guests needed to make coffee in the common area. Fairies arrived early and started coffee and stocked breakfast goodies which were perfectly adequate. Overall it was a clean and quiet stay."

"Amazing property with all of the amenities you could want. Really spacious master bedroom, hot tub, and game cabin that the kids really loved were some highlights. All of the appliances, electronics, etc are high-end and well cared for. Hosts were excellent communicators, and the muffins and well stocked coffee supplies when we arrived were a thoughtful touch. Just a few things to be aware of: (1) no dishwasher, (2) located off of a main road where cars and trucks travel fast, and (3) three of four bedrooms in the main cabin are up a steep and narrow set of steps, so those rooms may not be ideal for people with mobility issues or young kids. Overall, we had a great experience and would definitely stay here again."

"Clean and friendly Good coffee and waffles"

"."

"We enjoyed our two night stay. The room was clean. The staff were great!!! We ate in the restaurant and the food was tasty, especially the garlic butter. The price was good as well."

"The owner was very easy to communicate with and we had great instructions. The setting is beautiful and we had everything we needed for a relaxing stay. "

"Comfortable cabin with beautiful views of the river. Enjoyed our stay and plan to visit again."