Search Shelter Island Cottages

"Beautiful studio apartment and truly a retreat from our busy work schedules. Nice response from host when we had questions. Lovely location and truly inspiring..."

"Eunyoung and Mark have a beautiful home and have created the best “home away from home” for travelers. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and look forward to returning next summer!"

"Great place to stay! The house was very clean and well stocked in the kitchen. Made it very easy to cook meals. Our family and two small children had a great time. The hosts had great communication and made sure we had everything we needed! Would definitely book again!"

"Lovely home! Beautiful view! House has everything you need."

"What an absolute Gem of a VRBO rental! My son & his future wife own a home in Madison so the Clinton area was perfect for our stay. Jamie was a wonderful host providing snacks, soda and coffee during our stay. The unit was spotless, and our one question was responded to quickly. We’ll definitely be back - actually in June for the wedding. Thank you Jamie for the hospitality!"

"Pleasant !"

"I booked this for a sister weekend. It was perfect for what we needed. It appears that the house was built to be a summer getaway, so it is pretty basic and no frills and comes with all the creaks and quicks of an older house. The living room is perfect for hanging out and the four chairs make it easy to rearrange to suit your needs. The kitchen is nicely stocked with everything you would need to stay with a family and the dining room is spacious enough to easily accommodate everyone staying...

"My friends and I had a great time staying at this adorable cottage! The beach is so close and the parking pass is a lifesaver! We also loved making a fire and relaxing in the backyard. There was plenty of room in the kitchen to cook while spending time together. Will definitely book again!"

"Positive experience, great location, and cozy accommodations for a centrally located family weekend."

"Great trip! We could hear the ocean from the cottage and the view of the beach was beautiful. We played tennis, basketball, hiked, rode bikes and took many walks around the community. The cottage had everything we needed and the grill was great too."

"Comfortable, well appointed home. Beds were comfortable. Everything was super clean. We were very pleased with our stay and would definitely return."

"The house looks so cute and cozy, but when you walked in and around, the house was up to date and spacious. All amenities and necessaries were provided for a wonderful stay, albeit way too short for such a lovely place."

"We enjoyed this private spot right on the water and the cozy cottage that had everything we needed."

"Another great stay in Cutchogue. Our 6th year visiting the north fork and we couldn’t be happier with our accommodations and host!"

"We went to Long Island for an event and this house provided us with a very comfortable place to stay! The house was clean and well supplied; the deck and yard lovely and provided nice privacy. There is a pool which is quite nice but we did not use it. We highly recommend this rental!"

"Tucked away near the sound….a piece of paradise ! Truly a beautiful place to unwind and enjoy all the North Fork has to offer . Centrally located on the North Fork, but easy access to a spectacular beach . You will leave refreshed & trying to figure out how soon you can return ."

"Lovely place to stay beautiful location. Carl was super responsive and accommodating. Thank you!"

"Perfect place to stay for the weekend! We had a lovely time. The cottage was adorable in the host was very helpful."

"The home was very much as described in the VRBO listing, the booking process was secure, arrival, check-in and checkout were well coordinated, communication with some delay, regarding nonworking cable TV, otherwise excellent experience."

"Has everything you need for 2, for a Summer stay. (The portable heater didn't keep up with the December evenings)."

"Best affordable hotel in Montauk"

"Good family friendly resort! Hope it’s a heated pool.. Easy Check-out before 11:00 am!"

"An amazing stay with our girls!!! Can’t wait to go back!"