Agritourism Carlisle Hotels

"The house was charming and quirky and filled with character. We all fell in love with it! The bedrooms were spacious and the living space was great. We loved that the dining table had room for all 8 of us. The grounds were beautiful and the kids loved catching fish, roasting marshmallows and playing on the swing. The location was so convenient but away from the crowds. The host responded to our questions and needs promptly. We had a great stay!"

"We needed a place to stay and host small gatherings of family/friends for our son's graduation from Dickinson College. Fontinalis was the perfect solution. The hosts were accommodating and very responsive. The house was historic and comfortable. And the grounds were park-like. We had a wonderful stay! Thank you."

"Very nice quiet place. We will stay there again."

"Enjoyed our trip with our doggo. The downstairs rental had surprisingly large bedrooms and a very large bathroom, which was nice where we had little ones running around. It's a historic building so if you like the vintage charm and quirks, it's great and a great value. If you're accustomed to more polished accommodations, this may not be for you. the yard is huge and my kids had fun playing in the snow. Also, there are goats next door. Did I mention the goats?"

"The property was so beautiful. I had my husbands 40's surprise party there and everything went well. I was not expecting a lot of people to show. When I booked it I said a small party and well in the mean time my mother got really sick and the planning for the party was so sporadic an unorganized because of what I was dealing with during my mothers sickness. I did not remember how many people I invited and well a lot of people wanted to celebrate Andrew's 40th birthday. He has a lot of family...

"Excellent communication with the owners! They lived in the home and did an excellent job bringing this old home up to date. It has everything you could need, very clean, quiet and comfortable! Love the fire pit and the wine :D"

"Family and friends stayed for our family reunion in Newburg. The home was comfortable, clean and well stocked. The host was amazing and was quick to respond to any questions."

"The house is beautifully updated and has everything you could possibly need. I loved walking the property and my grandkiddos came over and ran around in the yard. Everything was accurate, well thought out and Wendy clearly cares about your comfort while staying with nice extra touches everywhere. Highly recommend!"

"The place was very well maintained and comfortable and exceeded what i was expecting. The landlord was able to help when something went wrong due to our mistake in timely manner. Overall a great experience"

"Beautiful cabin and property. Lots of seating and room to enjoy the whole family together. Many amenities and thoughtful items, such as soap bars, shampoo, toothbrushes, coffee, games, fishing items, fire pit with wood, and basically everything you need for a fun, enjoyable time. Wonderful property that is so close to Gettysburg, and staying in a piece of history at the same time. Absolutely perfect! Our whole family could be in one place for our daughter's graduation from Gettysburg College....

"Much older home with 2 bathrooms ,one on second floor and one on third floor . There was an awful smell coming from the tub on 3rd, floor. My son being a plumber said it was not vented properly. Bedrooms were all upstairs 2nd and 3rd floor, very comfortable beds and clean, Stairs were narrow and hard to climb for the older ones staying, especially just to go to bathroom. Only 1 parking space for property so any extra vehicles had to park elsewhere away from the house, We had to be dropped off...