Lodges in Shelter Island

"Holiday family tradition!"

"Everything was perfect. Only disappointment was not being able to get a couple’s massage or even at the same time(understandable as only one person working in the spa) and was looking forward to sitting bybthe indoor pool to read and relax but they do not have chairs only benches. Jacuzzi kind of small also. Overall we really enjoyed our stay!! "

"Yes"

"My stay with Saybrook Point Resort & Marina was amazing. Clean room, amazing staff and amenities! I plan to return again!"

"EVERYTHING about our stay at Gurneys was wonderful. The staff was outstanding and so accommodating. The room was beautiful looking out at the ocean. We have decided to make a family tradition to go to stay."

"Nice decoration, clean amenities, good stay"

"The staff couldn’t have been nicer! Courteous and caring. The room was immaculate with all necessary amenities. Somewhat dated but not shabby. Very close to town. Parking was ample and right outside my door! I attended a concert at the Kate and did not want to drive an hour home late that evening, so this was perfect for me. Much more reasonable than the other places in the area. Depends on what you’re looking for. Won’t hesitate to come back again!"

"Had a wonderful stay at The Bentley Hotel Southampton. The room was spacious, stylish, and spotless. I especially loved the record player — such a unique and thoughtful touch that made the stay feel personal and relaxing. The overall vibe of the room and the layout were perfect. Staff were friendly and the property felt well cared for. I’d definitely stay here again and highly recommend it."

"Everything was amazing! Friendly service! "